Maybe I got a magical eyeliner because mine comes out very very black. I like this eyeliner, but I do want to try different ones. It has certainly lasted me longer than the Revlon one did (a whopping 2 weeks before there was none left). It lasts all day and doesn't smudge if I have a good primer. If I sleep with my makeup on (I know, bad) I will wake up with this still on. It makes it easy to do winged eyeliner as well.
i just bought my second tube
this liner works well for me
its not black black but i dont like that anyway
This eyeliner comes out a washed out watery light gray color no matter how I tried it. It doesn't even show up on my eyes and barely shows up on the back of my hand. Total waste of money.
Awful product. Smells bad and gives a weak, watery line. Find a dying black permanent marker, soak it in water and trying using that. That's pretty much this product.
horrible product,came out like a faded sharpie marker, when i claims to be HD haha... scam
I bought it in Extra Black and it came out watery and with little black. I will not buy this again. It wasn't too expensive all of $6.20 but I need JET BLACK not wimpy watery barely there black. Not impressed. I do like the tip tho because application is good for my needs that's a thin black line, no wings. If anyone knows of an extremely pigmented black please let me know as I bought E.L.F., Wet N Wild, Essense Jumbo liner and now this with NO luck in the past couple of months :( Thank you.
I bought this about a month ago when my other eyeliner died. I couldn't find any of my usual favorites in black, so I opted for this instead. This isn't the best I've ever tried, but I do get a solid black line without having to go over it several times. I store it upside down so maybe that helps. I only had a problem with it not being black enough the first few times I used it. Eventually the ink started flowing & it looked very black.
this lasts sooo long for me. I usually have it on by 6:00 am & don't take it off until about 9:30 pm. I don't reapply or touch up throughout the day. On my eyes, this doesn't smudge, smear, or transfer what-so-ever, but it might if you have oily eyelids. Overall, I don't find this as sub-par as everyone else & I will most likely repurchase as soon as it dries out.
The pen tip works great, however the color payoff is terrible. I was expecting black and it came out a watery grey color.
I was really disappointing with this product. The only thing great about this eyeliner is that you can make a nice line without smudging, but other than that the color isn't even black it comes out looking grey, and it doesn't last very long either.