Personally this mascara was a huge disappointment for me as I've tried and love many Maybelline mascaras, but this one just didn't meet my needs. I found it barely added any length or volume and gave me a very natural look to me lashes whereas I prefer a big bold fake eye lash kind of look. Additionally I noticed quite a bit of flaking and smudging during the day too.

This is one of my holy grail mascaras. I already have naturally long lashes and this adds just a little extra and separates them nicely but the biggest reason I love it so much is IT NEVER CLUMPS! It's a great mascara for a real natural look. Repurchased 3 times already!

I was disappointed when I tried this. It didn't do anything to my lashes!

If you are looking for a lengthening mascara, this will cut it...but if you are looking for a thickening mascara,,this might disappoint you. I'll give it four lippies anyway since it doesn't smudge or flake.

Yuck. I thought I'd love this mascara, and I DO like the fact that it leaves my lashes nice and soft. But it's ridiculously clumpy and almost IMPOSSIBLE to remove--it took me twenty minutes in the bathroom with a ridiculous amount of makeup remover, soap, and water. Also, the wand is a freaking nightmare. It feels flimsy and I don't like that it can turn.

Not worth it, sadly.

One the only Maybelline mascaras I dislike. This did absolutely nothing to my eyelashes. No volume, length, nothing. Very disappointed in this product and is a waste of money.

This is the first mascara I ever had. I love it so much. The wand is iffy for some people, because of the shape. But it is really not hard to work with at all. The consistency is a bit dry, but I really don't mind. Everyone has different preferences for the wetness of their mascara, but I am the type who doesn't like super wet mascaras. This is a mascara that you either fall in love with, or hate it. I fell in love with it. I have been trying to finish of my other mascaras so it is currently not in my collection but as soon as I need a new mascara, I am going back to this one!

I have no idea why this product has a low rating. This is the best mascara in the universe. It is lengthening, volumizing, and curling. The brush is amazing. The blackest black is flawless and bold. It's only $6. It also washes off easily with my Neutrogena Gentle Foaming Cleanser (make-up remover). It doesn't flake throughout the day. It lasts all day. What else could I ask for?

Has got to be the best mascara i have ever tried. Especially with the second coat, my lashes look false! Definitely will be repurchasing!

I really like this mascara. I actually love the gel texture surprisingly... I was looking for a natural looking mascara and this wasn't that natural but it's so light and you can forget you're wearing mascara with this. My favourite thing about it is how the brush is so fluffy! It's skinnier than I though it would be but still fluffy. It gives length on the first coat and volume on the second. This mascara isn't a holy grail but I like it. The formula is smooth, light and doesn't dry brittle. I will definitely get a lot of use out of it. I got this in washable because I don't really use waterproof anymore