I got the refreshing foot balm I guess the formulas appear similar due to the glycerine content which may be high but the product smells sooo fresh its cooling and smoothing- instant softness and makes the feet softer and less tried in the long and short term- suits my hyper sensitive skin perfectly no allergies despite scent- love it and highly recommend- very modern and clean scent and packing v decent price.
It is good for me but I use cheaper creams.
I get it for my mother and grandfather who have diabetes and bad cracks on heels. They have tried lots of different brands and this is their by far best cream.