I rarely review anymore but I just had to say I am in love with this! These are like magic. It only takes the lightest touch to make them go on super pigmented. Blends beautifully, and when I wear it like eyeliner it doesn't budge at all! I bought this as a replacement for my favorite urban decay bourbon eyeliner, and this is better because it is the same color, more intense, without the chunky glitter! Plus it's half the price of UD.

I got curious when I saw so many great reviews on these & decided to buy one to compare to my NYX jumbo eye pencils. I got Brown Deluxe which is a deep, metallic bronze-y brown color, it cost me around 8 dollars.
I love Milani's eyeshadow eyez! This pencil sets and it really stays! It didn't crease at all and the staying power is fantastic! I usually use it as a base but it doesn't even have to be set by an eye shadow- it can be worn on its own. I like it better than NYX's jep to be honest.
I would definitely repurchase and try other available colors! continued >>

This is a great product. I have it in Brown Deluxe and it is strong and expensive but it is a good pencil.

About me: NW10-15 (neutral-cool toned, very fair), blue eyes, Color season is True Summer, Baumann Skin Type is OSPW.

I own this product in Deluxe Brown, which is a bronzey color. These make for a great cream shadow and primer base for shadows. They are somewhat stuff, but can be blended out when using a small synthetic eye brush. Great drugstore product.

i bought this to wear with the new wet and wild sugar and i was surprise how it doesnt fade it lasts a long time. i am going back to cvs to buy more my new eyeshadow primer works just as good if not better as UDPP!!

I went to cvs to buy some wet n wild eyeliner. I have never seen milani at my cvs. Ever. And today. I saw it and I freaked out a little inside. Anyways! I tried to find the liquifye eyeliner and they had run out. So I decided maybe I'd try the shadow eyez pencil. I don't remember any reviews on it. I just know milani eye products are generally pretty good. This does not move at all! I got the purple one. And I tried it out and I am going back to get the brown one! Maybe more!

I have these shadow sticks in three colors, Champagne Toast, Brown Deluxe, and Royal Purple. They are all fantastic. I bought them to replace my Estee Lauder shadow sticks, which dried out and fell out of the tube. These are so much cheaper and better quality. I use them with primer, but if your lids are not oily, you don't need it. They stick to the skin like paint. I use this as shadow and liner, and sometimes I apply them from the pencil and something a dab a brush on the pencil and apply that way. These are very pigmented and creamy, so the brush application method works well if you have a tendency to overdo it. The Champagne Toast works well to highlight the inner corner of the eyes, and I use the Brown Deluxe as a blending color. I can't say enough about how good this product is. I paid apiece $6.79 at CVS.

let me first say that I have REALLY oily eye lids, and to make matters worst my eyes naturally have like a billion creases on each eye lid. I can wear the shadow eyes with NO primer and NO powder eye shadow on top for a good amount of hours! its a miracle! absolutly NO creasing on any of my billions of creases :D
Keep in mind that MAC paint pots crease on me like crazy! I would have to use another primer under the paint pot and set it with traslucent power. Also I want to add that nothing stays on my waterline for more that 5 mins, idk if this is safe for the waterline but I've had no irritating to my eyes and IT STAYED ON! for HOURS!!! ladies, this product is a must, especially if you just want to wash this over your lid and blend it up to your crease with your finger for a quickie out the door. I've never written a product review on makeupalley but I just HAD to for milani.:)

I have the whole set and the only one I am not completely thrilled with is the white one. The others are amazing. They don't crease or fade on my oily lids. They aren't quite as long lasting on my lower lash line, but everything migrates there. I love these and hope they come out with a hot pink and a black one.

These go on super creamy. After they set, it doesn't budge! Awesome product for the price!