Pencil works excellent for me, but gel is not so good.
The Cosmetician promoted this product thinking it would be so good for me and I was excited to try it. The pencil was very, very hard and made little or no mark on my skin - in fact it scratched the skin under my brows. I thought maybe I had a part of the pencil that had hardened, so I broke abit off and tried that but nothing changed.
I thought the shape of the lead was great and the packaging was just fine.
Great dupe for Smashbox's Brow Tech To Go ($30 at SDM). It is the same product for a fraction of the cost. It has a slanted waterproof twist up pencil on one end and a tinted brow gel on the other. It comes in 3 shades. Blonde, Brunette and Dark. I purchased the shade Dark as I found the Brunette was too ashy for my liking. The Brunette shade also seemed darker that the "Dark" shade I picked up. Application using the pencil was smooth and it lasts me the whole day. My eyebrows still look perfect at the end of the day. I picked this up at SDM for $16 CDN with tax.