i got earth and retro they came in the morning so i decided to put earth on my lips then wash my face and do what i usually do did not budge when i dried my face, i swatches them my hands and rubbed my hand over swatches like crazily and not even smudge, i put the retro on my lips later and kissed my hand to see if there was anything and nothing so cheap and such a great product , very cream, not drying as i suffer from chapped lips and thought it would dry my lips out but no, because there that creamy you hardly have to apply any pressure at all defo buy again . Retro is a brilliant blue based red like macs Russian red or ruby woo something like that and earth is a peach rose nude lip , i have very pale skin and both suited my really well

I bought this in "earth" when they were having a 35% off sale. Earth is a nice nudey colour. It does seem to wear very well and when i tested this on the back of my hand it didn't rub off at all no matter how hard I was rubbing it. The only grip i have with this liner is that it's quite drying (which is probably due to the fact that it's WP) and i wish that it applied smoother. It seems to take quite a bit of work to get an opaque color. I like the color and would buy this again in different colors since it's pretty cheap. Around $2 on sale :)