Out of the the five I own, this is the only one that was disappointing to me. I love the rest to death, but this doesn't cut it for me. So glad I got it on a trip to the US and not here in Canada where they run about four dollar more expensive.
The other nude colour was much too dark for my very fair skin, so I swatched this and on my hand it looked lovely - a nice nude with pink tones in it. Awesome!
On the lips, not so much. It's sheerer than the Baby Lips, which is ridiculous, and unlike the other lip butters it's hard as a rock. The other lip butters are the more smooth, nourishing and pigmented HG product ever, but I literally had to jam this into my lips to get anything out of it. And that "Anything" was nothing but a white, gritty looking colour that settled into lines for the five minutes it showed up before completely vanishing.

I really wanted to love this because the other lipbutters are true to color, but this came out like almost white, rather than pale peach :( I will be exchanging it for a better color for me. This one isn't as pigmented as the others I have.

So, the store ran out of Peach Parfait, so I was like : I guess I'll take Creamsicle. So I bought it. And I didn't like it. I'm fair, with black hair and eyes. My cheeks flush a lot, so I don't bother wearing blush. This sort of washes me out. And it was pretty expensive, and really little product inside. I found out that if you rolled it down, it gets smushed on the sides, which is even more of a waste. I don't think I'll purchase any more lip butters. I guess it'll look good paired up with a Maybelline Baby Lip.

When i bought it, I was looking for a beautiful and delicate nude lipstick. The first time i apply the lip butter it was soooo happy! The color was beautiful on me. I was going to school but when i arrived to my locker... No color, only small waste in the corners of my lips! Went to school take me 2 minutes in car! I will not buy it again.

Although the colour looks great in the tube, it didn't turn out well on my lips. I also found that it didn't adhere to my lips very well. It seemed to be moving around all over, every time I would smack my lips together. Plus, be aware of any dried skin on your lips, it easily gets caught and makes it more noticeable.

Im an NW20, very fair skin lady... and i Love all things peach, orange etc. This is exactly what i thought it was going to be... a CREAMY ( ie milky) color with orange pigment in it. im not sure why people were so surprised it was a milky color. its called creamsicle not orange slushie.
You need to have super soft exfoliated lips for this color to look nice... it highlights all cracks and flakes in the worst way...and its definately for fair skin ladies or the dark skin lovelies who like the Niki or Gaga look... be bold at your own risk.. its def not for everybody.

Ugh, this color gives me the case of "jizz lips". It REALLY settles into any fine lines I have as well. I really wanted this one to work, too. I have to layer MAC's Sock Hop over it for the shade to be even slightly wearable. Damn. Still on the quest for a wearable nude peach that doesn't look milky.

I hate to be a negative Nelly here, because I do like these lip butters, but I LOATHE this shade. Peachy nude? Not quite. More like shimmery almost white. I'm very fair with black hair and blue-green eyes, and this washed me out so badly and made me look sickly. It is so much lighter than my natural lip color that it just looks really ugly and unflattering on. Hate it hate it hate it.

Ok, I've just gotta rave. This product is an AMAZING nude lip color for extremely fair girls. Seriously, if you are quite fair and always the lightest or second lightest foundation shade in all lines, give this lip product a try! It's not concealer-nude- rather it's a very light peachy-pink color that compliments my fair skin better than any other lipcolor that I own. Paired with a pale pink blush, it makes my complexion GLOW. I apply about 2 coats to get an opaque, but not caked-on, color, and I always apply it on top of moisturized lips (I use Aquaphor) If you have very fair skin, I can almost guarantee that you will prefer this shade as a nude rather than Creme Brulee. I own both and very rarely reach for CB, but reach for this product several times per week. Please, pale girls, do yourself a favor and get this lip butter! It's an HG item for me and I will never be without it.

I liked the strawberry shortcake lip butter, but this colour is a bit light for me. It settles into my cracks. I can pull it off if I put foundation over my lips, though.

This shade reminds me of a glossy, more sheer Soft Nude. It really is a nice nude option for summer (esp. since it isn't too matte). I prefer more of a pinky nude, but this works well too with a light hand.

This is a peachy nude, but do not apply too much. If you do, most of it will congeal on your lower lips. To me, there is nothing special about this color. I won't even use it for a quick sweep of color. I've tried about six or eight lip butters, and the two best colors are Pink Truffle, Fig Jam and Red Velvet. All of the others including Creamsicle are not worth the money.

The color inside the tube is a light peachy nude, which I really like. The formula is great. The texture is very creamy and not drying at all. It doesn't last very long (2 hours for me), but I don't really mind that, as it isn't supposed to be a long-wearing lipstick. There is a faint creamy smell to it that I really enjoy. The packaging is very nice, especially for a drugstore lip product. The only thing I don't necessarily like is that it's sheerer than I'd like it to be. I know it's a lip butter and all, but there are quite a few other shades that are more adequately pigmented than this one. It doesn't really show up on my lips unless I do lots of layering with it. This will probably show up better for people with less pigmented lips.

Love it! The perfect nude lip!! <3 continued >>

OMG, I have always wanted "nude" lips, those luscious, sexy nude lips I see others with but never could find that perfect nude color. I bought this last night holy crap I FOUND IT. this is the most gorgeous perfect nude EVER. I am so in love with this stuff. this stuff is very creamy and I would actually call it a lip balm then a lip stick as its just beyond creamy, I feel like I have on lip smackers. since its so creamy the color does not stick around long u have to apply constantly but that ok, I can't complain, like i said I have been looking for this perfect color forever. LOVE IT.

Most overrated product EVER. I think I just got a bad shade for my skintone (my lips must just be super pigmented because a lot of products look VERY milky on me and it is one of my pet peeves. Disgusting!) This shade is very milky on me and is not moisturizing in the least. It is just a glorified lipstick. I don't understand why they are toting it as anything but. You also get VERY little product for around 7.00 which, for drugstore, is rather expensive. I do like that you can see the shade through the top of the packaging so kudos for that.

I bought this and cotton candy at cvs buy one get one half off. These lip butters are amazing, and so far creamsicle is my favorite. It looks like a peachy nude, its very moisturizing, inexpensive, And they are pigmented. Next im gonna get tutti frutti and raspberry pie. I cant wait ;)

creamsicle is a light sheer peach lipstick.it's verry moisturizing,brings enought color to the lips,it's pale but nice on the lips!with a nude lip liner,this lipstick would be nice!verry nice color for summer! I sometimes,mix it with a dark nude lipstick! Verry pretty! Love it!