I loveeee this so much fav makeup ever so pigmented !?!?

I had really high hopes for this eyeliner, and I bought it especifically for my waterline. It is extremely creamy, doesn't tug and it is really black, so soft that it has to be applied with a light hand. BUT it smudges on me. It doesn't go all over my undereye area, but it smudges to the side, right under where i do my winged liner. I've even tried not to eyeline my eye all the way to the end of my waterline, but still, most of it just disappears and some goes to the side of my eyes after about 5 or 6 hours of wear.

This is great for lining your top lashes, but it itches like crazy when applied on the waterline. My eyes are kind of sensitive, but they only turn red from other khol liners. This literally itched.
When used to line the lashes though it didn't smudge at all. Has a good staying power also, but I will not repurchase probably.

I love black eyeliner and this one is pretty decent. very creamy, glides on without pulling or anything. doesn't smudge -big plus here! my mother has watery eyes and all the other kohls I got her end up under the waterline after 10 minutes!!!-

I use this mainly on the waterline and it's a matte dramatic black that I love. it lost one lippy with me because it irritates my eyes just a bit. they are very sensitive though so the fact that they are only mildly irritated rather then blood red and watery tells you alot.

won't repurchase as I'm still looking for a brand more suitable to my sensitive eyes

I’ve been looking for a decent, well pigmented purple kohl liner for a while. this is the best I’ve found. I have this liner in Deep Purple/Ultra Violet: it’s super pigmented and creamy and long lasting (and cheap at £4.49 ). It also has a lovely sparkle.

I applied it on my lower waterline and it stayed put for about 10 hours in hot and humid weather. It did smudge a little bit, but not too much.

I also used it as a base on my upper lid with a purple cream liner on top, and it made the cream very intense. This also lasted all day :D

It’s also very easy to apply with a brush, if you want a winged look. Make sure you set it or use a primer!

Unfortunately, this pencil is difficult to sharpen as it is so soft. I found that I had to put it in my fridge before I could sharpen it. I’m not sure how long this pencil will last as it is so soft!

Apparently you have to twist this pencil at the base to open it up - i tried to twist it, and the end of the pencil was definitely some kind of twisting thing, but if thats the case my mechanism is broken! Bad packaging!

That said, I will definitely buy this again, maybe in a different colour, as it is cheap and pigmented. The purple really is pretty though!

It's all in the name I guess... 'Drama'.
I bought it because I like to wear black eyeliner but I don't have the time to put in on with a brush from a jar everyday. Hoping this would be a good alternative, I wanted to give it a try. At first I was hopeful. The liner goes on very easy and it's a nice, deep black. After about half an hour I started noticing the first smudges around my eyes and it only got worse. Within 2 hours it melted away, leaving my eyes looking smudgy and panda-like. I tried it with and without primer, I used black shadow to set it... It keeps smudging. I guess I'll just have to get up a bit earlier everyday to put on my trusty Inglot gel liner... With a brush.

amazing. super pigmented, stays on and extremely creamy, so you don't have to pull on your eyes. best eyeliner EVER :)

This is my favorite pencil eyeliner.
It stays on all day without smudging or fading. I don't use it on waterline, though. I line my upper lashes with it.
This is much better than Milani liquif'eye liner which is really similar. The difference is that Milani liner crumbles when I try to line my lash line with it. My lashes are very uneven and they don't grow on straight line, so I have to move the liner back and forth to get it applied evenly. This liner does the job, whereas Milani liner crumbles in between my lashes.
I've been looking for this kind of soft and liquid'y liner for long time and I'm so happy to find this.
It's affordable and very pigmented and applies softly and easily. I use the black one myself.
Lining my eyes have never been so easy and fast and I don't have to worry about my liner to fade away during the day.
The only reason why I didn't give this one five lipsticks, is that it's very difficult to sharpen. Very similar than Milani liquif'eye. The material is so hard that my older sharpener couldn't perform. I had to use my newer one and also had to use a lot of force to get it sharpened.
Anyway, I love this eyeliner and will repurchase it, definitely.