So these have their good points and their... not so good points. Overall, I have to say these land more in the plus column for me but your mileage may vary.
So, first off with the things I like - Great pigmentation, standard packaging of a sleek and slim tube that contains a decent 7mL of product, easy to use doe foot applicator. Slightly thick textured but not tacky, this is definitely a hybrid liquid lipstick/stain as opposed to a shiny gloss. Lasts a good 4 - 6 hours on me, especially if I take the time to work the colour into my lips properly and wears away fairly evenly when it does start to fade. Requires fairly decent precision when applying, particularly the brighter and deeper colours but when applied properly, they look fabulous and last beautifully.
Onto the uncool stuff - castor. I hate this. HATE it. Surprisingly, this is about the only castor inclusive product I've been able to bear using. It's like they've shoved in some sort or vanilla or sweet scent over the top to disguise it but it still has a plasticky/chemical sort of scent when first applied. Fortunately this dissipates fairly quickly for me and is not noticeable after a minute or so but YMMV, obviously some are more sensitive to certain scents than others.
You can't apply too much or try and layer these with other products, they just go a bit gummy and streaky and look uneven. I've found the best way is to apply a light layer to my lower lips and then smush my lips together repeatedly (I look like an idiot but the cat doesn't seem to mind) until it seems pretty even, then just touch up my cupids bow. You can use a fingertip to work the colour in more firmly, this helps it last longer too. Then you have to clean your hands or you leave little pink finger dabs all over the nice clean white tiled bathroom, heh.
That's it really, I have several colours, Bonfire, Strawberry Jam, Pinky Nude and Buttery Nude. They're not a gloss you just swipe on before running out the door and they definitely require a bit more effort than a normal stick lipstick but once I figured out how to make them work for me, they're pretty good.
I have this in the shade Nude Peach Fuzz and I'm impressed by the opacity/viscosity of the product. The color stays vibrant and where you put it, application can be a bit fussy (a la OCC lip tars), but once on I found that this stays in place and fades evenly after a few hours, not leaving a ring around your mouth like some similarly textured and pigmented lip colors would. I also like that despite being very "stay in it's place" and shiny, it's not sticky.
The one downside though is the smell/taste. Castor seed oil or (ricinus communis seed oil as it on NYX's label) is the first ingredient and while it's great at holding pigment in lip colors, it smells pretty yucky. Fixing this is easy though, I added a singular drop of pure peppermint oil (only one drop is needed, extra could really irritate your skin!) and now it smells like mint instead of plastic.
I'm looking forward to trying more of these and really like having these as a high-performance, cruelty-free and budget conscious option in my makeup wardrobe.
I'm reviewing this lippy based on one particular shade I own since I havent tried the rest and I probably wont bc i dont need to. I own nude peach fuzz and I must say this is just perfect. The color is beautiful, super pigmented but buildable so If i want just a tint i applied a little bit or a lot if i want full coverage on my highly pigmented lips. Just wear a lip balm as a base and this will look gorgeous and last a few hours. It has a very light scent, that doesnt bother me at all its almost like baby powder but it goes away right way. Make sure you blend with ur fingers, learn how to play with it and u will love it just like me, ive been wearing this every single since I got it :)
So thick, it looks horrible on my lips. Goes on with a big line going across my bottom lips. Shows every line in your lips and is gooey. I will try putting it on with my fingers because I hate to throw it out but I have a feeling its going in the garbage!! Saw this product on Pinterest, I should have come to makeup alley for the reviews before buying it!!!!
I have this lip cream in Natural. I like the color and consistency, but.. The smell... It literally smells as though I am putting my daughter's play dough on my lips! It's border line unbelievable. I'd love it if it smelled better. Yuck.
I got this in a set with 5 NYX lip products. After I bought the set I swatched all of the colors on my hand and I was SO excited to wear this one (in the shade natural). I have neutral-warm fair skin with a lot of redness.
Pros: super pigmented! Comparable to OCC lip tars as far as opacity.
- Super thick! I have to dab this product a few times for it to not appear goopy. It is opaque enough and does not need to be so thick!
- the color natural looks disguating on me. It brings out every ounce of redness on my face, and I think this color is too cool for my lips. It just looks like the gross frosty nudes that people wore in the 90's. This would probably look beautiful on tan skin tones.
Overall the formula is very promising so I think I will buy this in a different color and update my review later on.
Not impressed.. Love other nyx lip glosses but not into this at all.. Basically a liquid lipstick and super thick looking at least for me.. Won't buy more
I really like the way this product looks on my lips but the smell is absolutely disgusting so it's impossible for me to wear this product for more than a few minutes. I have the colors Pinky nude and Strawberry jam and am very pleased with them. They are not as drying as the Soft matte lip creams but unfortunately the smell prevents me from wearing them. Would not repurchase. For me this is a 2 star product but other people might not find the scent as offensive as I do so it wouldn't be right to rate it so low.
I just purchased this in the shade "Natural" and I was pleasantly surprised at how good this product was as I've heard from several raves from youtube beauty gurus :) The price is reasonable and despite the fact that many people hate the scent of this product I think I quite like it :o It applies quite opaque (I recommend blending it out with your fingers) and lasts incredibly long. It's a lovely peachy nude shade which suits my light-medium/medium skin tone. I love it!
NYX Xtreme lip cremes are pigmented and give full coverage on my lips. Long lasting. Has a faint smell similar to Play-Doh that does not linger. I have this in Natural which is a peachy nude and applies slightly darker than the tube. This applies like a softened cream lipstick as opposed to lip gloss, even though it is in a lip gloss style tube with a doe applicator. I wish there were more colors.