i had high hopes after reading the reviews. the mascara did do a good job magnifying my lashes, but unfortunately after a few hours of wear i have raccoon eyes. it just doesn't stay on my lashes. the search for my low-cost, every day mascara continues.
I've tried a lot of mascaras, and this one is definitely not bad. For me, it does add some volume, length, and seems to hold curl. It doesn't flake. It's relatively cheap. However, I do get clumping, and while it's a nice, dark black shade, it is a little dry looking. I will use up this tube and I'm glad I tried it, but won't repurchase. From NYX I prefer Doll Eye, and I am always on the quest for my HG, so I don't re-buy mascaras very often.
Love it!! I got this and Doll Eye (Volume) at the same time. Tried Doll Eye first. It looked beautiful at the beginning, but seemed to disappear sometime during the day, even though there were no smears or smudging. So I tried PME--and it looked great even 15 hours later. Took me a few seconds to realize that PME kept the curl in my lashes so you could actually see them. No smudges or smears, and comes off easily with cold cream and a wet wash cloth. This could be HG...
Top Notch product. Mascara of choice when I go to Ulta. Its a true all in one, thickening, lengthening, volumzing, the holy grail of sexy lashes. Dramatic lashes with a deep black pigment and it holds curl as well. Five stars!
I've tried pretty much every mascara. My lashes are dark, short, and straight. This is some good stuff...it's cheap, it lasts, it doesn't clump or flake, definitely adds length and volume, and it's not horrible to remove. Very black. Highly recommend.
I LOVE THIS MASCARA! No clumps, adds length & volume, curls & separates lashes. Two coats are all you need. It lasts all day and will not smudge! I'm already on my 2nd tube. I got it for $8 at Ulta.
I'm going to start with the one reason I don't like this mascara: It takes a lot of rubbing to get off. I use oils to remove my mascara, followed by cleanser, and still, I am left with smudges under my eyes.
That being said; this mascara goes on really well with two coats, holds a curl, has not flaked on me - not a single time, lasts all day and night, and gives a nice, deep color.
I was looking for a less expensive HG mascara for a while and this is definitely it. The brush is super soft. It gives my lashes lenghth and volume with one coat with no clumping or flaking. Its cruelty free and I cant say enough good things about this mascara. I bought it for only 6 dollars from a nyx seller on eBay.