love love love! lengthens very well.

It wasn't clumpy at all, and it did lengthen some, but sometimes the end would awkwardly bend and don't put too much or else your lashes will look spider-leggy

The fibers don’t always attach to my lashes, but it’s still a nice everyday volume + length mascara. Classic brush, slightly longer than average, which combs through lashes well. No clumps while applying; few flakes after a while; worth a repurchase. (Not any time soon, though, as I have 4 new GWP mascaras waiting to be used...)

I'm really liking this mascara. It really does add great length to my lashes, without causing clumps. It helps to brigten my eyes. Maybelline makes great mascaras amidst the awful "great" lash.

I was really excited about this,but it didn't live up to my expectations.
It doesn't hold the curl, and I find it ggettibg under my eyes and starting to not look as great in the middle of the day. All in all, I wouldn't recommend this and am still on the search for the perfect mascara:(

This mascara can be good, if used with other mascaras. This one does what it says, it makes lashes noticeably longer. But it clumps your lashes together really bad. I have long lashes anyways, but this mascara always takes them that extra mile. I use L'Oreal Million Lashes before Illegal Length and a clean Colossal brush after, to separate the clumps. Also this mascara works best if you use it quickly on your lashes. I'd buy it again to add to other mascaras, but I wouldn't wear it alone.

Ouch - I got fibers in my eye both when putting it on. And again at night when I was taking it off with remover and a cotton pad. And while I was using the computer mid day I had trouble seeing and realized I had a fiber in my eye and had to use Visine to get it out.
I had been looking forward to using this product because of my medium, straight lashes.
Going back to Maybelline One by One, MAC Plushlash, and Mally Voluminous.

In my opinion it's okay, but that's it. Just okay. The fibers hang off of the end of my lashes at weird angles and don't create that length that I imagined it would. I was a bit disappointed with this mascara. It lengthen my lashes a bit, and doesn't clump up or anything...

Just no impressed with how this makes my lashes look. It does wear really well and resists flaking. I usually pass this over in favor of something else though, even if the other product does not wear as well.

LOVE THIS. when it comes to makeup the only item i ever really care about is mascara. saying that i've tried so many different products.. but rarely do any of them work on my thin, straight, short asian lashes. i picked this up from walgreens on a whim and haven't looked back since. i bought the waterproof formula and holy hell my lashes look amazing and stay all day/night. the only trouble is with taking it off, it takes a bit of effort.

I hated this Mascara. I had such high hopes. When I applied it these little fibers just stuck On the end of my lashes at weird angles. My SO told me he hated this mascara the minute he saw it. Went in the trash : /

First impressions: Nice subtle length added. Formula quite dry.
Day 2: Clumped, and couldnt catch my lower lashes properly.
Day 3: I'm going back to Lash Stelletto (which I love).
I don't love the brush, I don't like anything about this stuff. Definitely going back to Last Steletto or Falsies.

HG bottom lash mascara. People were commenting on the formula being similar to my HG Falsies so I went and got this one. Love the packaging much more than the Falsies and it keeps a curl in my stubborn lashes, but it didn't volumize my lashes like the Falsies do. It did lengthen nicely though, so I mostly use it on my bottom lashes or, when I feel like spending time on it, I'll pair the Falsies over this mascara. I like it. Gals with stubborn Asians should give this one a try.

When I first picked this mascara out at Walgreens, I wasn't expecting much. I'll admit it... I usually don't think highly about Maybelline mascaras. However, this one did end up exceeding my expectations big time.

The mascara itself is $9, so if it fails to meet your standards, at least you can pride yourself in the fact that not too much money was wasted. It's a bit pricey for a drug store product, but it's not too much if you're used to experimenting with mascaras from high-end brands. First off, if you prefer dry formulas, don't purchase this. This formula is incredibly wet, and a lot of product is picked up on the wand. The bristles are very thick, but nicely separated out. Although the brush itself is quite large, it's shaped perfectly enough for capturing lashes at every angle. I experienced no smearing, even when using this mascara on my bottom lashes. If you look closely at the wand, you can see that the formula does create little wispy, "fiber-like" extensions that stick out from the bristles. These extensions do lengthen your lashes by a lot. It won't have that wispy effect once on your actual lashes -- which is a good thing -- but it will still manage to extend them out by a noticeable difference. I normally need a few good coats with lengthening mascaras in order to achieve what they claim, but with this product, one coat was good enough for both eyes. Also, the packaging is absolutely brilliant. The cap twists on instead of being snapped on, so this makes it sturdy for traveling. Really, Maybelline out did themselves this time. I'm very impressed!

The only negative thing about this mascara is how there is a huge risk for clumping. But, tada, I found a way around that! When using the wand, put very little pressure on your lashes. Don't go strong when trying to coat them; The formula is wet enough to be able to transfer without heavy impact. Light pressure and very little coating applied will make your lashes incredibly long without them clumping and becoming spidery.

Along with L'Oreal's Telescopic, this is certainly one of the best lengthening mascaras you can find in a drug store. I will most definitely purchase this again.

Just bought this at Walmart for about $5. This mascara worked well for me, better than my experience with the Falsies version. Illegal lengths did not flake on me, but falsies did terribly. This gives a clean, no clump lenghtened lash. BUT not like the comercial says it will!!! 4mm of extra lashes???? i dont think sooo!!! I had it on for about 10hours and no flakes. Washed off easy with soap and water. For 5 bucks you cant go wrong.

I had high hopes for this mascara but was truely let down. I have never had issues with any mascara like I had with this one. After I had a good thick coat on each eye, I noticed that it felt like I had something in both eyes (like an eyelash or something) but I could not find anything ( I am assuming it was coming from the "fibers"). My eyes were so irritated within about 5 minutes of putting the mascara on, they were burning and watering. I immediately washed it off (before it was even good n' dry) and the feeling like something was in my eyes went away as soon as the mascara was off, but the burning and irritation lasted for hours afterwards. So much so that I did not put mascara back on at all that day. I bought this at Walmart and thankfully they took it back, no questions asked and gave me a full refund.
I certainly would not recommend this product.

Illegal Length mascara should be illegal!! Ok so I wanted to try and see if this would give me some length....Well it did that all right. I really worked it let it dry and then did it again. Past the mirror by the bath room latter and scared myself!! Looked like I had spiders sitting on my eye lids! It stayed till very late at night. Then I took it off. Again and again. Those fibers were everywhere. If this is what it takes and what it is going to look like then I no longer want long lashes. I am happy tonight with NO mascara. Would I purchase again? What do you think!!

This mascara is pretty good. It hold my stubborn thin lashes pretty well and didnt flake at all. even after I take the masaras off the curls still remains. the smell is horrible tho, it's so strong and overwhelming, if the smell is lighter then it'll be my deff. HG

This mascara is at a reasonable price. The packaging is great. The tube seems pretty long and big for a mascara to me, which is good because you get more product. It definetly lengthens your eyelashes. The color is great. It does not add too much volume, but it's great.

So far i've only been using this for a few days, but honestly I'm not crazy about it. It doesn't length muchat all but doesn't clump either. I was gonna purchase telescopic from loreal but sadly they only sell black colors, when i perfer browns since i opt for a more natural look. I'll up date it if it turns out any better. Plus the packaging is okay but it feels like a cheap plastic bottle. Disappointed.