I'm very happy with this purchase and it has become my favourite black eyeliner. It's such a smooth, creamy consistency that goes on perfectly! Even without a primer this eyeliner is long lasting and if smudged straight after application can help create a nice, modern smokey eye.
I have only had this product for a few weeks and so far the product hasn't dried out like the MAC Fluidline. If it does dry out quickly I will edit this review. This is a main point of contention for me when purchasing a cream or gel eyeliner.