A versatile eye product: excellent results as both shadow and liner. Stays put like no other. Pigment: wickedly dark, steely grey. A winner.

This is by far the best eyeliner I have tried (MAC, Stila, MUFE, etc). It is completely FAB-u-lous for tightlining; lasts all day - and my workday goes from 5 a.m. to at least 7 p.m. Smooth, creamy texture, easy application. Highly recommended! Will definitely purchase again.

Love love love these caviar sticks. I first fell in love with Khaki, now Smoke. They are perfect for quick smokey eyes, can be as dramatic (or not) as you want. This is a very deep grey, just a little lighter than black. I do wish the staying power was a little better - it fades after 6 hours or so, even with UDPP. But I love it so much, use it almost every day, and highly recommend.

The caviar eye sticks debuted in fall 2011 with eight colors (smoke, steel, jungle, khaki, cocoa, sapphire, plum, and amethyst) and they're the most perfect liners, sharp or smudged. "Smoke," which is black with light shimmer, is my favorite and I'm patiently waiting for more colors to become available. Retailed for $24, it comes in a big twist-up pencil with 1.64g of product. The pencil is 1cm in diameter, which sounds thick for a liner, but you can angle it to get the width you want. Or, draw a thick line and blend it as a shadow. It's super creamy and easy to use. The color is highly pigmented and gives you an intensity that outlasts all other liners. Can't go wrong with this!