I am reviewing the color Pin Up Pink. It is a lovely lavender pink color and it stays on pretty well for a cheaper lip liner. I love the color as it is bright and feminine. The packaging is a 3, but what can you expect from a lipliner? That isn't me being cruel, as it is nice for lip liner. I do think a twist up liner would have been more user friendly. Over all, I can't complain and I will buy this brand again!

Smudge resistant. Great color. A deep candy pink. Purchased at Sally Beauty for $5.29. I want to go buy some other colors

I bought this at Sally's in "Petal to the Metal", a matte dark hot pink/fuchsia. I have used it several times, mostly as a base with Illamasqua's Corrupt lipstick on top (some people has given me compliments when I'm using this combination), and it works really well. It is definitely waterproof and has a smooth application. Can't wait to try other products by this brand!