This is my first MUFE eyeliner and I LOVE it! It doesn't smudge at all and I have oily eyelids. Most importantly, I'm in love with the color! Although the makeup artist at Sephora told me it wouldn't work with all skin tones, I'm medium-tan with dark brown eyes and it works very well for me. If you want to try something different then brown or black eyeliner, I would try this one !
Although I do have these eyeliner's in two other different shades, the burgandy shade looked terrible on me. After applying it looked like someone beat me up. The shade was just very unflattering on me, but at least I now know to stay away from burgandy shades for my eye area.