Get this in clearence. When I first get it I love this, I walked in rain and it did not move at all, jet black, really easy to apply. but after about one or two month it start to sheer out, not as black as it was, and run easily, not waterproof and does smudge if I don't put eyeshadow above it.

this is NO way is smudge or water proof. that was the main reason why i bought this. i live in florida and during the hot humid summer you need a good quality water proof eyeliner. sorry this did not meet my expectations at all!! :(

Somebody has a new HG!!! I totally adore this liner!! It creates a thick black line that stays all day! I go from first to sixth period with perfect dark eyes. It does not smudge (unless you rub your eyes) and doesn't run. This is by far one of the best eyeliners I have used. Now I'm off to go stock up on these. I don't know how much these cost at CVS or Walmart, but I got it at Grocery Outlet for only $3!!!

I gave it 3 because it does smudge very easily and it's a light back tone.. but that's just my preference of wanting it a darker colour. The pen itself is good because the tip is quite precise upon applying it.

I can't believe people have had so many issues with this eyeliner! I absolutely LOVE it! It's one of the best liquid eyeliners I've used.
The packaging is kind of plain. It's just a simple white body with the information written on one end in a plain silver font, and topped with a black cap.
The pen tip provides a hassle-free application compared to a brush.
I noticed that others have complained of issues with smudging and messy packaging. I've not experienced any of those issues. The eyeliner seems to set/dry almost immediately. I can look up right after applying and not worry about that dreaded black line marring my eyeshadow. I also don't experience the packaging issue. The cap is a little difficult to remove, but not so difficult that my hand jerks back toward my other hand. O_O

I didnt like it at all. The cap is so hard to open. Every time I open it, I get some one my hand. Just messy and annoying.

This didn't work. It smuged so easily! It says waterproof but it's not!!! Not buying this agian.

Terrible eyeliner. Smudges so easily even with primer for me, it was a complete waste of money. Got it at a local shoppers drug mart in canada for around $8. It didn't give a proper solid line, nor was it nicely coloured. It looked really patchy and not very pigmented. I've found better from other places. Had higher hopes than this.
Would not recommend to anyone other than my worst enemy ( :p )

this eyeliner pen set me on the journey of eyeliners. If you are new at eyeliner, definently start on this kind of eyeliner. There are ups and downs to this eyeliner. after its been used for a while, it dries out a bit. All you have to do is run it under room temperature water and dab a tissue on it, and its good for the next week. If you want a flick at the end, this is not the best eyeliner for you. Also, it supplies a thick touch. so if you want the line to be nice and thin, be careful!

I am use to using Maybelline waterproof liquid eyeliner. I think it is called Line Works. Anyways, I tried this because Ulta had a buy two get one free. So I bought two of their mechanical pencil eyeliners and got this free. I'm glad it was free because it wasn't work the price they were asking for it.

First off let me mention I'm not a fan of eyeliner pens. They never seem to work well or if they do its at the first few uses, then the tip gets wonky (deformed) and you can never get a nice fine line. You are essentially at the mercy of a poorly designed product. An eyeliner pen sounds wonderful in theory, but in reality it is usually utterly useless. So is the case with this product.

The formula was not opaque enough. It was watery and did not last very long. My little cat-eye wings would disappear after a few hours. I used this product a few times and then threw it away and stocked up on the Maybelline liquid eyeliner when I found it.

Try if you aren't looking for a that super deep, fine black eyeliner. I wouldn't bother with it again, personally.