Ah, another Philosophy bargain find on the shelves at my local Marshalls store. I've been enjoying my Pink Frosted Layer Cake 3 in 1 and am finding this one just as much fun. I can only speak to 2 of the 3 in 1 elements as I've never tried to use these products as a shampoo and I'm not sure just how much product you'd have to dispense to get a decent bubble bath. I gave up after one capful. This product is too expensive to waste this way and I'm not a big fan of bubble baths anyway. However they are great shower gels and that's why I buy them. The lemon fragrance is light and luscious and doesn't stay with you after bathing or showering which is just what I like.