This is definitely my HG and I can not understand all the negative reviews.
I like it much more than the version with oil.
I have very sensitive eyes 'cause I am wearing contacts and I am using this for 8 years (at least, I do know exactly).
I tried many other brands, but nothing can even come close to this.
I literally use it to take off my eye makeup while my contacts are still in!
No burning, no scratching, it leaves my eyes completely clean, without any residue (even though I am often using hard-core stage makeup & waterproof mascara).
It feels like water a bit & it is incredibly cheap as well.
Worst makeup remover I've ever used. Stings my skin, and could not even clean regular eyeliner. Really want to throw it away
It's cheap. In every sense of the word. It burned my eyes and I have never had that happen with any make up remover. It barely removed my eyeshadow (which was a nude shimmer so hard to even say if it did) and didn't make a dent in eyeliner or mascara and I had to scrub hard to get even a little eyeshadow off - not nice on the eyes at all.
Vaseline works better than this.
This will be a bitch to use if you have heavy eye makeup on. It can't even get rid of all the eye liner. I literally have to use vasiline to take of the eye makeup, then use this product to take off the vaseline. You get what you pay for I guess.
I swear by Balea makeup remover (bottle, not wipes). I wear contacts and have quite sensitive eyes; I don't wear waterproof makeup, please note. This formulation leaves no greasy residue - no residue of any sort - and never stings or irritates me. It removes my mascara and concealer and shadow easily, effectively, and quickly. I have to get mine in swaps with friends from Europe, as I don't live near enough to Canada to hit the Shoppers Drug Mart, sadly.
I just finished off a bottle of my highly loved Neutrogena Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover and thought I would pick up and try a few more economical brands to search for a substitute. Balea happened to be one of the two brands I purchased at Shoppers Drug Mart on sale for about $6 for 120ml bottle. It claims to "gently remove eye makeup without irritation" and is "enriched in pro-vitamin B5." I do like that it doesn't sting nor burn my eyes, but it really isn't that great at removing eye make-up overall and doesn't make a budge in water proof makeup. Overall I'm personally disappointed and wouldn't repurchase.