I wanted to like this masacara since this is the type of wand that works best for my lashes and I've been a loyal Bobbi fan since day one, but...it left my lashes with little volume and when I tried to apply more I got some clumping. I checked in with it later and it looked like I needed to curl my lashes again which I never need to do with other mascaras that work for me. I am very sorry to say, but I've found drugstore masacaras which look much better. On the plus side, it does have a nice, natural look. This might work for you if your lashes don't need much curl or volume and you don't press wand too hard into your lash line as the wand is very hard.

This might be the best mascara I ever tried. I wasn't expecting that from BB. Still, this lengthens like nobody's business. And the color is extremely dark. I think I've found the one. I never thought anything would replace Million Lashes by L'oreal.

I have purchased the full size of this after receiving a sample in my bellabox. This is the best mascara I have ever used, it is HG material for me. Only downsize is the price, wish I could find a cheaper dupe! I find this really separates my lashes and adds length without making it obvious that I am actually wearing a mascara. I wear this over my Dior maximiser lash plumping serum and I get added volume too. Best eye combo I've ever tried!

I was given this mascara in the editions to Bellabox and since it was my first ever bobbi brown product I didn't know what to expect. I am so pleased with this, it is wonderful! It lengthens my already-long lashes even longer and separates them beautifully. The brush applicator is plastic and is shaped in a spiky way if you were to look at it from a birds eye view from the tip. It is really lovely and I believe will please many more.

The area around my eyes is really oily, so most mascaras tend to smudge on me. But this one didn't! Even though it's not waterproof, i did not notice any smudging AT ALL. So it's a decent product for me. The product itself is really smooth so it doesn't clump at all.

But the price is just a little too much for something just decent. I suggest just going for highstreet brands.

It's been a long time since a product has disappointed me this dramatically. I received a sample size as part of a GWP, and tossed it after just one month. It's low-end quality with a high-end price tag. I have very straight lashes, and this would not hold a curl for love nor money. More irritatingly, it clumps, so it looks like you have spiky little lashes. I find that I also tend to smudge with this mascara. At the end of the month, it was also drying out. This was all the things I hate in a mascara, and I'm so glad I didn't actually pay for it.

I love how this mascara lengthens my lashes but it doesn't hold the curls.

Read here for the complete review:
http://jesroque.blogspot.com/2011/11/review-bobbi-brown-lash-glamour-extreme.html

Sorry to rain on the parade! It really did look great right after application, however it is undependable for me. It noticeably smudged after only a few hours and even a tiny amount of water caused flakes that smeared. Imagine having a drop of rain hit your lashes and to have black smears everywhere! I live in the city and walk/take transit often, can't take that kind of chance. Too bad, a miss for me. I wish more companies made tube mascaras!

I was a member of the Dior Show cult, but this mascara in plum has converted me. It's a hard color to find at the moment, but JUMP ON IT IF YOU FIND IT. First of all, the lash separation is unparalleled.

Something about using plum vs. black makes my eyes look brighter. Also, if it smudges it looks like you have cool purple eyeliner as opposed to raccoon eyes.

Omg, words cannot describe!! I have tried every mascara, you name it, and this is by far the best. So many mascaras flake during the day and end up on my cheeks, but this one did NOT budge. Also, it defines my lashes really well, and does lengthen as well!! There is also some added volume which can be built up with more coats. Also, the price is decent considering the prices of other high end mascaras. Definitely try it, I'm really glad I found this one!