I have the old one - brown and new one - transparent. I like the old one much better. I would rate the old one 5, and new one 2, so the average rating is barely 4. The old one somehow made eyebrows look more made up without looking drawn on the face. The new one just make them stay put for some half an hour:/
this product now does not appear in the catalogue anymore i do not know if it has been discontinued but it is a very good product having asian features means less of brow and eyelahes. this makes it look better that it was. it is brown in colour but it does not make the lashes look brown. i have only 1 left now and am really sad that if it is discontinued. i like natural look in lashes and this gives a natural look and does not run even in hot weather.