Pros:
It's black
Easy to use

Cons:
Smears easily
Does not stay on all day

This was the first eye liner I have ever purchased and used. I am fairly new to this whole make up stuff so I went with this because it was cheap and seemed easy to use. Although it was easy to use since the applicator is kind of big, it did not stay on nicely all day. I noticed it smeared. It is a great eye liner for beginners.

It's a pretty good eyeliner for beginners who are looking for cheap, drug store brands. I used to love it. It was the only eyeliner I used but as I got more into makeup I would try out more high end brands & I found a lot of better stuff. It's still a pretty good eyeliner. It kinda smudges and you have to reapply it every few hours. But it works good and it's really pigmented. I also like how it's retractable instead of the wood pencil kind. continued >>

When I first bought this eyeliner I really loved it. It's a dark, rich black and the eraser on the end does help to blend it and smudge it out. I thought the packaging was kinda cheap. I have a pet peeve about not being about to put the cap on the end of the liner while I'm using it. The cap had to set on my counter top and I know that's not a big deal but I'm more prone to losing caps that way. I believe it came with a sharpener (not positive on that). What I found over time is that the liner easily fades and also transfers and before I know it, the liner is all over my eye area. Not cute. Overall it's not a horrible liner but there are better, longer lasting options out there.

This is my go-to eyeliner! I love the smudger and the color is great, the only thing I don't like about this is, it comes of VERY quickly and fades through out the night..

like this eyeliner the only thing is it's in soft black. i didn't check the color before i left the store :(. it's a good eyeliner for going out at night. after a couple of hours of wearing it wears off.

This eyeliner does suck. Agree with the majority of reviews here. It dosen't stay put at all. I even tried primer, but nope. Still would smudge everywhere beneath my eyes. HATE IT

The smudger on the end of this liner is a great idea. Unfortunately the liner doesn't have enough color to hold up to a tender smudging. The liner comes off so fast, it's sad. So not worth it.

This is officially one of the worst eyeliners I've ever used. I liked the soft black shade, but within 30 minutes it had already smeared under my eyes (and I had only worn it on my upper lid). Back to CVS it went.

This is awful. And I use a lot of maybelline products. It smudges and runs everywhere. Within an hour its already completely off the fluidline and is all over the place. Worst eyeliner I have ever bought. It was cheap and on sale so I grabbed it, but won't ever again.

I really like this eyeliner its really smooth and soft and is easy to apply : )