I was looking for a navy eyeliner that is water or smudge proof. The cosmetician at Shoppers recommended this product and color. It's a black-navy blue color. I swiped it on my hand and yes you can definitely see the navy color. However this product was a big disappointment. It doesn't apply smoothly and, looked very faint on my upper lid. I tried sharpening the pencil a few times and it didn't help. Paid around $20.00 Canadian and returned it.
All of Lise Watier's liners are simply right up there with the very best made anywhere, at any price. What's extra nice about these is that they are made by a Canadian Company AND they are reasonably priced compared to some brands that are no better quality (and perhaps worse).
I have this liner in Marin also - a nice navy blue - but wanted something darker - not black, not navy but a bit of both and here it is in the aptly named Bleu Noir (Blue Black). This is such an intensely rich colour and it's just out of this world sultry on brown eyes. This has to be my favourite eyeliner (along with LW's Eyeshine pencil in Smokey Brow). It applies beautifully, remains smudgeable for a minute or so and then, when it sets, it's there all day and will not fail you or travel wherever the heck it feels like by the end of the day. And it comes off completely with a good eye makeup remover or cleansing oil. They don't get any better than this for quality or colour! If you can get one of these, GET IT!!!