If you have sensitive eyes like I do, this is a great mascara for day to day use. My eyes get irritated from mascara very easily, but this one almost never bothers me.
Now you're not going to have the most insanely thick lashes. This stuff is best for a natural look. It gives my eyes a nice boost. I've already bought another tube.

Usually I'm not a big fan of mascara, but I really like this one! It feels very light on my eye lashes, (like I'm not even wearing any mascara) but my eye lashes look extra long and look very natural which is what I like. I found my mascara with the try me free label on it back in November, so i was actually able to to try the mascara for free after the mail in rebate. I would recommend this mascara to anyone who doesn't like the crunchy feeling of regular mascara or is looking for more natural makeup products.

WORST MASCARA EVER!
maybe i just got a bad one, but when i opened it, it looked like i had left it siting open for a year. IT WAS SO DRY! and i typically like dry mascaras.
this stuff was was like 8 years old dried out crap.
it was flaking all over my face even while i was putting it on and all day.
DID NOTHING FOR MY LASHES. absolutely nothing.
and it BURNED so bad when i took it off (i do not have sensitive eyes either)
CRAP!
i threw it away after i took it off and it almost burned my eyeballs out.

Since switching to more natural and organic makeup products, this is the first natural mascara I've used.. So I really don't have anything to compare it to. BUT...I will say that overall I love this mascara. (and I'm EXTREMELY picky about mascara) The first time you use it, it works great(usually it takes mascara a few weeks of usage before it gets thicker) it has texture that's very easy to work with and build able. Being that it washes off extremely easy, after the day is done you may have some faint coon eyes. Just be sure to powder well under your eyes because moisture is what gives you the coin eyes. It doesn't flake on me, and I've been using this mascara for a few months now. I would give it 5 stars, but the fact that it's so water soluble is the only downside I see.

I love this stuff. i have tried high to low end mascaras before, from pretty much all drugstore brands (covergirl, loreal, maybelline, etc) to high end (clinique, lancome, bobbi brown, etc) and i really really am impressed w this product. i rarely repurchase mascaras & its like im always finding something wrong w them. This one i have since repurchased and honestly couldnt be happier.
the formula isnt runny, its buildable, it has the ability to look natural and to look dramatic depending on what you want. i love that it is organic because i am done using harsh ingredients and chemicals near my eyes. the packaging is seriously cute, and i normally dont even care about packaging. but most of all, it doesnt make my long lashes spidery or clumpy. it makes them look like themselves, but better- and natural but still a bit dramatic to add some pizzazz. and the best thing is, the formula conditions your lashes or something bc i have noticed that when i take it off, no more breakage and it leaves them in amazing condiiton! and i swear theyve grown since i started using this. overall idk how this product will work for others, but for me its a godsend. i will keep buying this!!! kudos to physicians formula for making a great, natural product that really delivers.
PS in addition to the one in the green tube, i have also purchased the one in the black tube as of yesterday. i think it claims to be volumizing or something. i will report back! continued >>

Pros: Organic, ingredients I can read, is very light and does not weigh down lashes, creates a natural look, wand is recyclable.
Cons: Flakes after 6 hours or so, needs retouching with q-tip as applied, formula is a bit dry, price is a bit steep for drugstore brand unless you can find it on sale.
Not sure if I will buy this product again.

Definatly my favourite mascara ! I love everything about this product and it is the only mascara i every buy. Gives good length and volume without looking fake or unnatural.
Although, remember to replace it about every 3-4 months as it starts to smell a bit planty because of all the natural ingrediants.

I think this is a great product. I was looking for a relatively inexpensive mascara that doesn't test on animals like L'Oreal or Maybelline. I found this at Target and I've heard great things about Physician's Formula so I gave it a try.
I love this mascara! It promises no clumping and the brush doesn't clump. It also adds thickness which is nice because I don't just want long lashes.
Two things I have to point out:
-sometimes the end of a brush gets mascara on it but this doesn't like that--it doesn't get the little tail of mascara, because it looks like a longer brush with the end cut off. It doesn't really taper, but there is some mascara along there (obviously because mascara covers the whole brush) and it has a rough edge to it. Around where the bristles are, the outside of it, it suddenly ends roughly and the side/end has mascara on it. I tried scraping it off and it is a very very thin layer but the shape of that ending is just strange and I couldn't get all the mascara off. Just interesting, I thought I'd point it out.
-It feels very watery and that's why it gets a four, not a five. It doesn't smear too much but I have to be really careful not to rub my eye and even if it doesn't smear, it feels like it is doing so.
But overall, I love this mascara! It looks very nice and is very build able. It doesn't even smudge on it's own so just be careful not to rub your eyes.

I would be completely in love with this product if it would not give me raccoon eyes, only 5 minutes after putting it on. Other than that, this is my favorite mascara.

I think this is my new hg! I wanted to try an organic mascara and this one look cool. I have to say I love it! It adds just the right amount of volume and lenght and leaves my lashes soft to the touch. It's also very easy to remove with just water! I haven't had any smudging and I've accidently left this on when I go do high impact work outs.

When I discovered this web site http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ i browsed all of the makeup I have! I was so shocked almost every product can be unsafe at some point. So I started looking for more healthier options, although I loved my CG Lashblast and Revlon Colorstay. This PF mascara is organic, and is quite nice, i don't find a strange smell, comparing this to other mascaras, smells fine, some of them smell like tires! I like the packaging, it's a different design. I personally prefer plastic wands because they seem to reach every single lash and i don't have to apply coats and coats. I admit that I was very skeptic about an organic mascara, i was in an affair with Lash Blast for about 4 or 5 years, i bought it when it was launched and since then i haven't changed, ive had Voluminous which i also like very much, but i always came back for my precious orange tube.
I think Organic Wear Jumbo Lash mascara, its a decent mascara it does:
Volumizes
Holds a curl
Takes off easily so i don't loose lashes
Its Organic
The only Con i found, is that if i wear this for a long time, eventually it gives a bit of racoon eyes, i believe it may be because of my oily skin and that i've always worn waterproof mascaras, which are more difficult to take off. Almost all of the non waterproof mascaras ive tried have this Con, except maybe for Lash Blast. Still, i would recommend to try out this mascara.

Ugh, I usually like pf products but this was a waste. It clumped, smudged and made my long lashes look stumpy. Got this in a bogof deal and gave both away.

I tried this brand because my eyes are bloodshot and I thought maybe it was because of the brand of mascara that I use. Physician's Formula claims to be hypoallergenic. Well, I should have saved my money. This flakes into my eyes, and I have a raccoon-like appearance after a few hours of applying it. I agree with a previous review that the wand seems practicallly empty even on first use. I wondered if it dried up while on the shelf at the store. I won't buy this again.

Physicians Formula Organic Wear Jumbo Lash mascara is pricey compared to its performance. I've used this mascara for a month and I wouldn't recommend it. This mascara flakes and there's barely any product in the bottle! I pitied myself after I bought this mascara because it clumps too.. The mascara does not stay true to its name. Don't be overly persuaded by greenwashing! There are WAY better healthy mascaras out there that do the legwork! Keep looking!

I have to use natural and/or organic make-up because my skin is so sensitive due to the medications I'm on. I was using Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes! and was attached to it. However, it is a little pricey so I decided to give this a try when my last Tarte tube ran out.
For me, it's the same results as Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes! but for half the price. The packaging is cute, but bulky, but oh well. The Tarte mascara was the the same. The wand took some getting used to, but after a day or two it became a non-issue for me. I'll be buying this from now own instead of Tarte. Sorry, Tarte!

I got this mascara as a free trial offer which I am glad I did because I would not have purchased it on normal circumstances as the price is pretty expensive ($17.99) for a drug store brand. However, I was really surprised by the results of this mascara, the formula did not make my lashes clump or flake off at the end of the day. It really makes my lashes long and separated evenly and it's also easy to take off (I use olive oil). I am torn because although it did such a good job I don't know if I would pay full price for it, I think I would pick it up again if it were on sale.

Normally I research all my products before I buy them, but I happened to be in Target and decided to check out Physician's Formula. The ingredients didn't sound too bad like so many brands claiming to be organic and natural but aren't. I was specifically looking for a mascara with a big fat brush like CG Lashblast and this is it! And at a drug store price too?! Even better! I actually like this BETTER than CG Lashblast! I love the volume I get with this, the almost fake lashes type of volume. And it does not clump too bad. Maybe just a little, but it is fairly easy to brush out. It smudges a very tiny bit sometimes. Other than that I love everything about it and the packaging is super cute!

Through swapping on MUA I have slowly been accumulating Physican's Formula products that I had never gotten around to buying at the drugstore. This mascara came as my most pleasant surprise! I have long been a user of Mabelline Great Lash Mascara, which is wildly popular. But I wasn't 100% satisfied with it because even the waterproof formula seems to melt off after a couple hours, and it didn't make my lashes as full and defined as I wanted. This organic wear jumbo lash mascara in ultra black gave me everything I was missing from my previous mascara. It left my eyelashes big, full and slightly curled, it wasn't clumpy or sticky, and I didn't end up with the dreaded raccoon eyes after wearing it all day. Plus the leaf container design is really cute, and I feel better about using a product that contains organic ingredients. This is the best drugstore mascara I have tried and I would definately recommend it and buy again!

I do like, recently iv only been using all natural/chemical free mascaras but there a pain because you can only purchase by online ordering and there pricy so im finally just going to settle with a drugstore one. I do like that its cheap and fairly natural. It gives good volume and length but throughout the day it thins on lashes and looks limp. It can get a little clumpy so just take your time. The huge brush is a pain, its very messy and hard to get the small lashes. It also does flake and smudge onto lower under eye, but i think thats mostly my concealers fault. The packaging is pretty but i feel like the inner tube is so thin, i feel like your not truly getting a lot of product.

I normally prefer lengthening mascara to volumizing, but this may have converted me for good. The formula seemed a little dry, but that might have helped with separating my lashes so I won't complain about that. My lashes are short and very sparse. This mascara really thickened them nicely, and even gave a little extra length. I do wish the wand was a bit longer, but that might just be due the the fact that I am accustomed to the longer wands that lengthening mascaras have.