I got this mascara after my DiorExtase began to show clumps.
It retails less than USD10, inexpensive I must say and worth every cent !
It reminds me a lot of Majolica Majorca's mascara..... lengtens, and doesn't clump at it. Doesn't volumise much, but volume is buildable upon layers. Coats every single lash with it's comb-like brush. While it is water proof, I must say that it removes pretty easily with oil-based make-up remover.
Doesn't smudge and last all day..... Definitely a steal, and a great find. Will definitely repurchase this over and over again.