I wasn't expecting much from this one when I got it but it is AMAZING. I wear waterproof Cover Girl LashBlast, which is extremely difficult to remove, and this takes it off easily. I soak a cotton pad in this remover, hold it over my eyes for about 15 seconds and all my eye makeup, including my mascara, comes off easily with no tugging. The packaging is cute and pink and the opening where you pour it out isn't too wide so I don't spill it everywhere. I sometimes have trouble with makeup removers making my eyelids red and flaky but this is very gentle so that never happens. The best part is, it's only $5! I will definitely repurchase. I was previously using Sonia Kashuk Remove but I will buying this from now on.

This is a great makeup remover, especially for eyes and waterproof makeup. I used to think the garnier 2-in-1 makeup remover was my HG makeup remover, but this may be a contender for the title! Effective, doesn't irritate my eyes and inexpensive. So good!

Love this stuff. I didn't have to scrub or tug at my eyes and it didn't smear my makeup around. Cheap and easy to find at the drugstore. I will repurchase.

So the packaging is what originally attracted me to this product. It's pink. Come on. Let's be real. So I was wearing my regular face makeup.. which is a full face.. foundation..mascara..eyeshadow..blush you know the drill and I kid you not.. I had 2 cotton balls, Put a bit of this remover on them and it took off EVERYTHING. Not just my eye makeup.. but my foundation too. It does leave a slightly slippery-greasy residue so I went and cleansed my face with my clarisonic and facewash and I was done.
This cut my facial cleansing routine in half and I am eternally greatful (: thank you maybelline!!

Finally! Something that COMPLETELY removes my stubborn mascara. Don't forget to rinse it off. Skin feels nice and smooth, doesn't leave a tightness in the skin, no irritation, and it doesn't sting my eyes.

There are products out there that work a little better, but they're a bit pricey. This is the only drugstore product that I'm happy with.

It removed all my eye makeup but it seriously irritated my lids. Felt like my lids were burning. I looked at the ingredients and discovered that fragrance sits high up on the list. Super bummed out that this was a fail for me. If you're skin sensitive to fragrance then this one might not be for you.

This is by far the best eye makeup remover I have tried. It's cheap and it gets rid of everything - waterproof mascara, eyeliner, shadow - quickly and gently. I would recommend this to anyone looking for a good and cheap makeup remover,

This quickly and gently removes my eye makeup - even the waterproof stuff - with ease!!! I like it better than the Mac Cleanse Off Oil in its use and cost.

i like it! removes waterproof mascara easily. used to hate wearing mascara cause it's a chore to remove.
though it feels kinda oily, i just need to rinse off with water and i feel clean!
will repurchase.

This comes in a 70ml bottle and is sold as 'a gentle eye and lip makeup remover for sensitive city skin'.

You have to shake the liquid inside to mix it up a bit, as it contains two different layers.

It worked pretty well and removed all traces of my eye makeup (eyeliner, dark eyeshadow AND lash glue) very easily. Doesn't leave a too greasy residue and a little goes a long way.

Good value for a good product.