Very good gold eyeliner, especially for the price. Glides on nicely and is a bold gold color, not a shimmery light brown or faded light gold/champagne color. Can be blended for a subtle look, or you can make a bold line. Looks good with lots of shadow colors and lasts through a night out. It didn't irritate my eyes at all either, so it would be a good alternative to glitter if you want gold on your eyes.
Twist-up pencil is also great for easy use and maintenance.
Ulta brand products are usually buy 2 get 1 or buy 2 get 2, so you can usually average them out to an even better price. I would definitely buy this again if it runs out.

Very good long wearing eyeliner. I really love it. is the exact color of 24 karat gold (most gold liners I see are very much like light gold champagne color which does nothing for me). I actually have used this two ways. One is as a base for my gold eyeshadow. I will pencil this in to my eyelid and then smudge, then it becames a sticky enough base for loose eyeshadow. The second way I use it is Im using this is as inner corner and at the waterline. Based on my tan skintone, I cannot use white eyeliner. It gives a great eye opener..and This stuff stays put, no joke! as a base or as a pop of gold color in the water line. This Best thing is I got this for $1. This reminds me of Benefit Glided discountinued gold eyeliner. So I found the next best thing.