I really like this mascara, for the price its just as good as the mascaras i have tried that are much more expensive. I would definately buy again!!

This product was pretty much what I expected it to be, as I never have extremely high hopes for mascara (HE or drugstore). I love the packaging, and that's what really pulled me in! It's so pretty and luxe looking. What's inside, though, was a bit of a disappointment. It wasn't awful (it didn't flake or smudge or make my lashes brittle). It also didn't exceed my expectations in any way. I want a volumizing mascara, and this just didn't live up to it. If you're looking for a mild lengthening mascara, this is a good chioce, but other than that I wouldn't suggest it. I have yet to find that perfect mascara, but here's to hoping!

Great mascara.. LOVE the fullness and volume it gives to lashes.. my favorite mascara. the price u cant go wrong..

This product is one that gets better with age and a little coca cola. When i first got it, it was far too thick and wet, even with the brush it was too much and always looked like i had too much on. As a male, I want to look fabulous but like a fabulous boy, not a fabulous girl so natural looking, perfectly seperated and defined eyelashes are a must. Just a few drops of coca cola and a quick shake later, it was thinner and I'm guessing the sugar seemed to clear up the wetness issue. It no longer looks like i'm wearing mascara, it gives my eyes that wide awake and perky look I was after without the clumps and tarantula leg lashes that are too often sported these days. The brush is the best part of the product, i've never found another one that fans out and shapes my lashes perfectly. I don't find either that it falls off like other mascaras which is the worst give away ever. If they could resolve the thick gloop issue, this product would easily be a five!

This product is a bit to wet for me. Didn't do much except just sit there. During the day I noticed I had a bit of fall out under my eyes. I will use it up be use it up but won't buy again

I always come back to this mascara. It separates my lashes and lengthens perfectly. Wish it did a little more in the volume department but I still love it.

This is my favorite mascara it really defines my lashes and I love the gold tube it comes in. It lasts all day and has not been clumpy at all. I have already used a tube and am now kn my second.

I find that this product is a bit too wet and it doesn't hold the curl of my lashes for too long. I actually received this for free when I bought some other L'oreal products and I was really excited to try it out. It was a big let down for me! I just personally find that it doesn't lengthen, curl and hold my lashes in place... it actually weighs my lashes down!

I use this in conjunction with another mascara. This lengthens so well for me. I curl my lashes and wiggle this mascara and it does a beautiful job of making them look super long. I noticed at first it wasnt amazing but once it got tacky/dried out some it worked amazing for me.

I absolutely HATE this mascara. Doesn't lengthen, doesn't build volume. It's like I'm putting nothing on my lashes.

I bought this along with carbon black voluminous mascara a few weeks ago. Pros and cons.
Pros: nice wand idea, good for separating. light formula doesn't weigh down lashes.
Cons: no volume once so ever. Clumps easily.
This mascara just gave me the meh feeling but it works nicely in a combo with other mascaras. If you want great separated lashes that also give volume, stick with one by one by Maybelline :)

Not my favorite. The "automatic wiper" definitely doesn't wipe off much/any, and it's possibly the most flaky mascara I've ever used, dusting the tops of my cheeks. Also, it's clumpy and doesn't add any volume for me. And it smells funny.

I find that this mascara is very good. I lovee the packaging; it looks very expensive and high end, not at all like the usual drug store mascaras that usually look quite cheap. I really like the brush, I'm a big fan of plastic wand because I find they work better on me than the ones with bristles. It seprates my lashes and coats them evenly which defines them a lot. I would buy this mascara again, not a lot bad to say about it but it does take a while to dry because it's a very wet formula.

I got this at CVS for $4 because they were on sale for $6 and L'oreal had a coupons on a display.
The first time I used it, it flaked a bit, but after that, no more flaking.
It smudges and I get slight raccoon eyes.
Not very buildable (gets clumpy) and I did not notice a huge difference in my lashes besides a tiny bit more length (see picture).
The only good quality of this mascara is that it holds its curl very well. I went to a beach with one coat of this on (did not submerge my head in the water, but my eyes did get wet), and my curl held.

I am so let down by this; it FLAKED SO BAD!!! It's even more frustrating because I did like the way it looked and felt, etc, but I have never had a mascara flake this bad. I even specifically was researching a mascara that didn't flake, as I wear contacts...I got the black brown and the color was great.

This mascara didn't give any kind of volume or help to hold curl. However it did lengthen my lashes. I found that it clumped my lashes up a lot, and that the wand is very stiff.
~$25 retail price in Australia, that is wayyyyy too expensive.

I do love the packaging, but for that price I would rather use a different mascara that has better results.

I was really nervous to buy this! I love the falsies by Maybelline.. but it drys out way to quickly in the tube and has some flaking! So I watched a view reviews on this and decided to give it a try! I actually really like it.. I've used it 3 kinds of ways.. I've worn it with curling my lashes before and then applying. I've use it just brushing up.... and no curling...and then I've used it... brushing the tops of my lashes and then brushing up. I like it all ways... but don't apply to much because its very build-able.. but as you build more than you should it starts to get clumpy. It last all day.. and it holds curl all day... I love this! My new favorite.. So far I've been using it over a week and I've loved it since day 1.. haven't noticed any flaking....
UPDATE: starting to notice some drying and when putting it on.. it's clumpy... I dunno...what to think right now.. maybe a few more times of it looking like that..and my review is gonna turn bad:(

I am a huge fan of this mascara. It gives me great volume, holds curl (wp version) and decent length as well. The color is truly black and doesn't turn grey as it dries like so many other mascaras do. The wp version removes easily with cleansing oil (DHC). I am on my second tube of this little gem and I have no reason to even try another mascara. I get 16+hours of wear with no smudging or flaking whatsoever. Is has become a staple for me.

I love this mascara. I'm very picky about mascara (as are lots of people). I love how this mascara isn't flakey or clumpy and coats all the lashes. It makes my lashes look longer and fuller, but not clumpy and yucky. And, it doesn't give me raccoon eyes.
I used to think my lashes were short, but I think they are just really straight so you can't see them. When I curl my lashes and put this mascara on, they look great, long and lush!

I love this mascara! It separated each and every lash. It made my lashes so thick and I get compliments all the time! The only thing I wish it did was make my lashes longer, but I have naturally long lashes so it's ok. I am definitely going to buy this mascara again!