This has to be one of the worst liquid eyeliners ever. I expected so much more from Nars. This brown is really diluted and too light. The marker tip hurts because there's not much product coming out and I have to go over my lids several times. The worst part of it has to be that it balls up and comes off at the slightest contact with anything. I like putting eyeshadow over my liner and when I did, all the liner came off with this. Threw it away immediately. Do not be fooled by the brand and packaging, this sucks.