This is the first gel eyeliner I've tried, I got it in silver star, which is a deep grey. When I first received it the consistency was what I expected a gel eyeliner to be, but after a few weeks it seems to of dried out and I now need to add water to it to get enough on my brush to use. My eyelids tend to be on the greasy side and this seems to make this eyeliner smudge slightly or come off because it never seems as dark at the end of the day as when I first put it on. Will not be rebuying this product.
I have a lot of things to say about this product none of which are good things. I purchased this "Gel" liner in BlackBerry which was the purple tinted liner. I was really looking forward to an everyday liner that was all natural without harsh chemicals as my eyes have started to become more sensitive to eye make up products lately. Boy was I in for a surprise! When I attempted to use this "gel" liner, my brush hit the product and it was hard as a rock! I had to rub the product hard to get any color, and even with all the rubbing barely any liner was deposited on to the brush. My feeble attempt at a swatch the liner yielded nothing. There was no "Gel" to be swatched! The product was so far from being a "GEL" that I had to laugh.This stuff is absolute CRAP! And I can't believe I ordered it. Maybe I got a bad batch, but The fact that everyone has had a different experience with this product (some saying it's like a mouse consistency and others say it's hard and dry) tells me that the formula is VERY INCONSISTENT. It saddens me that I have written an honest review of this liner on their website and titled it "Horrible" and they did not allow this review to be posted under the reviews section for this sepcific eyeliner. It is clear that the company hasn't done much to improve the quality of the product regardless of the many complaints from people having the same issue of it being too dry and unusable. It tells me that this company would rather save face than try to fix the problem. I have returned this product and I am waiting for my refund. Since 100 percent pure is a newer company they should listen to their customers.
The worst eyeliner ever. I'd compare it to putting on watercolor as a liner. Doesn't go on even and smears right away.
AWFUL gel liner.
Was hard as rock. Nothing gel/cream like about it. At one point I open the lid, turned the container upside down, and the "gel" liner fell out as a nice ,round,soils pellet. I really wanted to like it. Hopefully someday the formula will improve.
Great packaging though.
I had the opposite experience than many reviews with the consistency of this gel eye liner, It was very soft, like a pudding. I had to carefully dab my brush in it. it applied well, similar to a medium brown color with light shimmer, great for green or hazel eyes. I had to not touch my eye and wait to apply mascara for ten minutes in order for it to dry and not be smudged. I was hoping for a harder product and tried leaving it in the fridge to help it harden but it is still softer than I want. I am happy that as a natural chemical free product it can be long wearing but it is just too soft to buy again.
It does not glide really good or smooth,
Not smell at all
This was very clumpy and hard to glide across my eyeline. It was a hassle dealing with the brush as well. I did not come close to finishing my pot before throwing out. Like the idea of fruit pigmented, natural cosmetics though.
I was really excited to find a natural eyeliner but this wasn't what I expected at all. It's not gel - it was dry, like solidified powder (you have to wet your brush to get any product onto it), it went on cakey, the more I tried to layer it on - the more transparent it became, it didn't last, and it didn't look smooth at all. Very disappointed.
VERY disappointed with this product. I read as many reviews, including videos, as I could! I thought 100% pure was a good brand, buuuut...ehhh.
The gel is a solid, I thought it would be..... a gel. It didn't come with directions either, so I just rubbed my eyeliner brush in it a bunch, which worked. (btw this stuff turns your brush hard, never had that problem with makeup on my brushes before, just paint!)
The color, eggplant, is a LOT more purple than I expected. I thought it was an eggplant tinted black , but it is more the reverse. I didn't really care for the color with my eyes, but thats just me - I thought it would flatter me more.
The MAIN thing is...IT DIDN'T LAST. It smeared more than ANY eye product I have ever used. I normally use powder eyeliner - both as powder and wet. The color is smears as is kinda cool - the more it smears the lighter it gets, which can be cool, but then the definition around my eyes was gone! IT was awful!!! I am, patiently, waiting for the company to return my email about a return - couldn't find anything on their website about it.
This a great gel liner! It stays put all day, even on my waterline. It seems to me to be pretty waterproof too! I was a little hesitant to buy this liner b/c I have the creamstick liner and it really bothered my eyes but this one didn't irritate them at all, yay!!! This is definitely the best liquid or gel liner I have ever tried! I was also worried that this was going to be hard to apply (I don't have a very steady hand or much patience) but it went on so smoothly and it was easy to get a straight line (I used their liner brush).