Got this as a Sephora VIB gift. Big oversized teddy bear brush, dry formula, doesn't thicken at all, lengthens a bit for a natural, fringey look. The best thing about it is that it really separates lashes. I've been using it after my mascara primer and before my Hypnose Drama and it's good at keeping my lashes separated. Overall, I much prefer dramatic lashes so this is not the look for me. I will not purchase a full size.

I got this a 100pt gift from Sephora. I like the brush & the packaging is cute. Just not sure if I would actually buy the full sized version. Hasn't done anything to wow me. I like how pigmented it is...but that's about it. It doesn't really hold my curl or any length/volume. I mean it looks nice right after, but it just doesn't stay that way. I do like that it doesn't clump up, even with the many layers I put on. So to me, it's 'meh' but it's not horrible. It's got some merits. continued >>

Love this mascara.I got as a 100 pt perk at Sephora and it's wonderful.People with short and/or thin lashes may not like this.Well,I have thin lashes but i still love it! I've used vitamin e oil to lengthen my lashes and this mascara just enhances them.This is best as a daytime mascara or for anyone who doesn't like dramatic lashes.It could be blacker though.I use it everday and am happy with the results.

This created beautiful volume for me in one swipe. But it flaked during the day. Also, I thought it could be blacker.

This mascara did very little for my lashes. Sure, it wasn't too smudgy, but it provided frustratingly limited volume and length. It was so wet, my lashes clumped together and additional coats were impossible to build. I prefer a dryer mascara that is buildable. Glad it was a sample! I wouldn't buy if it was in a drugstore for $10, so I certainly wouldn't at that price. There are much cheaper mascaras that do much more!

I wasted 100 Sephora points on this. The brush is too big to work with. It could easily make a mess because of it. The mascara itself does not do anything for me. Does not add length does not add volume neither. Although it doesn't smudge but it flakes. And it also makes my eyes itchy.
It might work for other people but I would not spend $19 on this.

This is my favorite mascara. It comes in a giant tube and lasts forever, and the brush is on the softer side so when I inevitably get in too close to my poor eyeball, it doesn't hurt as badly as with some stiffer mascara brushes.
Also, this mascara creates a beautiful fringe of lush black lashes.
I only buy this when I've run out of the little mascara samples that Sephora and other stores sometimes give out because it's quite expensive--but they ingredients seem quite nice (no parabens).

HG!! I love this mascara! It holds a curl, adds volume and length, is extremely buildable, and is the most beautiful black color! The packaging is adorable, too. I caught it on sale at Sephora for $10 and I had to get it. I am obsessed! I will be purchasing over and over.

I am extremely picky about mascara. I am searching for the perfect formula. I got this on sale for $9, but I wouldn't pay more. The brush is nice and flat. This formula is buildable with some clumps (not clump free, but not as bad as others I have tried). It does a good job of lengthening, but not much for volume. What I dislike most about this is that it smudges onto my browbone towards the end of my workday. I get black mascara flecks on my upper eyelid/browbone. Color is a nice, rich black. All in all, I won't purchase again, especially at full price.

I got this as a gift from sephora and I like it but not enough to buy it. It is almost as good as Dior Show and the brush is similar too but not ...great.

The wand is fat lol I love fatty wands cause I like how the length of the bristles brushes against my lashes. think how you brush your hair with a big brush but then you would think to get any mascara with a fat wand but the formula also what makes it amazing. I think it's supposed to condition as well? But definitely no clumping, lengthening & volumizing, so love, love, LOVE! continued >>

I got this as a free gift from Sephora and its actually not bad at all. It doesnt really add a lot of length for me. But it did add volume to my lashes! It didn't clump either. I wouldn't repurchase though. It wasn't the mascara Ive tried and it wasnt the worst either.

it is decent mascara, nut I cannot use the brush since its too big for my small eye lashes.I use clinique brush with it though

LOVE this mascara! I'm so picky with mascaras because I have sensitive eyes, and I can't tolerate flaking, smearing or clumping. This mascara is thick, and the wand takes a little getting used to, but once you get the hang of it, you'll have thick, LONG lashes that stay put all day and night. It washes off with soap and water, and has no irritating scent. I usually prefer a little more natural look, so I actually put a coat of this on top my regular curling mascara - on the top lashes only. It darkens my light lashes perfectly and adds the volume I need to highlight my eyes. On my third tube, and will certainly buy again!

I am wary of mascaras, i have tried so many that irritated my eyes. So for decades i have stuck to Clinique mascaras, which have never made my eyes burn. But i was offered this as a free gift at Sephora, so i tried it, as i have a number of other TT products i like.
Normally i don't wear black mascara, sticking with brown or brown black. But this doesn't look harsh, and is not clumpy or sticky or gloppy or fuzzy. And lo and behold, it doesn't irritate my eyes! It makes my lashes darker, longer, and thicker, although not ultra dramatic, which is fine with me.
It comes in a cute pink and silver container. I am quite happy with this, and i would recommend it highly for daytime, office, and casual use.

I have been using DiorShow for years and decided I wanted a change. I'm glad I picked this mascara. I have long lashes but this makes them look incredibly long. I love how soft it makes them feel too. Plus it is cheaper than Dior. The only con is that I don't get the volume I like, but it won't stop me from using it.

I got a sample from sephora when I bought my MUFE smoky lash and honestly, I tend to be skeptical when it comes to mini tubes cuz most don't do the full size justice. But I decided to keep this as my emergency purse mascara. To my surprise its actually pretty good. I'd recommend this mascara for those who are looking for a good quality mascara to get that natural lash look. For me it actually made my lashes longer, it wasn't dramatic length but it was noticable enough. Volume was minimal, didn't really curl my lashes...for me that was fine. All in all its a nice mascara for a day look, it enhances your natural lashes and makes your lashes soft, which Is the opposite of what a lot of cheap mascaras do.
A lot of people gripe about the price..$19 is about the average price of a mascara from sephora. So if u don't mind splurging on a nice mascara this isn't a bad investment.
I voted I would buy again, even though I didn't buy it lol but I would definitely consider it in the future.

Opinions of mascaras seem vary a lot based on the individual, but here's my opinion: this is honestly just as good as my other favorite, the DiorShow that comes in the fat black tube. No clumping, no flaking, no spider lashes--just beautiful, natural looking, Voluminous lashes. I was hesitant to try this when the brand first came out but I am very glad that I did since it's such a great alternative to the pricier diorshow. Plus, it comes in a pretty pale pink and silver tube (which, for me, makes it all the more appealing).

Recommend if you want NATURAL and dark lashes
Pros:
-Made lashes SUPER SOFT and dark not crunchy at all
-came off easily when washing face
-did not rub off on anything and lasted all day

Cons:
-Price (way too expensive)
-did not give my lashes volume

Got a sample from Sephora.
Pros:
- Made lashes dark and soft; not crunchy!
- didn't need alot
-was easy to take off and you could sleep in it if you had to without irritation
-i already have long lashes but the seemed like they were a little but loner
-stayed all day
Cons:
-too expensive
-didn't make my lashes dramatic or have alot of volume
**For someone who is not on a budget, wants natural looking lashes with out volume