Does nothing. I like the idea but the roll on makes me feel like I am tugging at my eyes and this can be irritating.

I don't like this product at all. I think that the fact that it is cold when you apply it makes you feel more awake, but I don't see any difference for my dark circles. It helps when you are tired and you apply it that by the cold of the stick your eyes seem more awake. Also the product doesn't dry quick so you have to wait some time until it dries. I would not recommend this to people that want a product that affects their dark circles, but it is not a bad product if you want your eyes to feel more awake.

HORRIBLE PRODUCT !!!!!!!! extremely drying, i had to discontinue using it every 2 days because my under eye area got so dry. the company people said that i had to keep that area well moisturized, who has the time to first apply a product that completely dries out your skin and then apply moisturizer on top of it every day !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I use this everyday. My eyes are prone to puffiness, with dark circles, a bit of bagginess under, and hooded lids. This really helps firm everything up and makes a huge difference in the hoods and bags. (That sounds so terrible lol). I have not noticed any difference in the dark circles, except that there is less shadow from the puffy skin. I apply in the am, to both the undereye and the lid, to bare skin before I apply any primer or other products. It does take a little while to work, I notice more of a difference an hour or so after I use it, and it seems to work better the longer you use it so perhaps there is a cumulative effect. The biggest benefit to me is the lids, there is a major difference in the amount of lid space I have to work with, and my eyes look much more awake. I stopped using it for a while and within a week had noticed a negative effect. Super easy to apply, feels good going on, does not irritate my eyes, does not negatively affect my makeup... the only negative thing I could say about it is that it does take a little while to dry.

I am surprised to see the negative reviews of this product here, because I quite like it. OK, I never get dark circles or heavy bags under the eyes to start off with, so I can't say that this product has any positive effect on those things. But my eyes are prone to puffiness (either from sleep deprivation or from over-sleeping), and this treatment does seem to noticeably reduce the puffiness, which no other eye treatment I've used has been able to do (and I've tried quite a few over the years, including expensive brands).

I quite like this. It is quite expensive for what is though and I wouldn't buy it if it wasn't on sale (I picked it up at 40% off) but it does make a difference to my dark, lack of sleep, circles.
It's not a miracle cure and I still need a good concealer but it does help a bit, I love the roller-ball applicator, and it feels cool and refreshing when you apply it.

it gives a nice coolng sensation to the undereye but i didn't notice any difference so i won't be repurchasing

This eye roll on did absolutely nothing and i don't like the sticky texture. It created a sort of film that rubs off when i apply make up on.

I haven't notified any change. I've been using it for a very long time, but it's never over. I want to try to another brand.

Thought I would throw my 2 cents worth in here - definitely did not impress me at all. I have used a caffeine eye treatment of MAC's and noticed some positive results but with this I saw no real effect. No less puffiness, discoloration, or anything like that. Didn't make my skin particularly hydrated feeling and that was the LEAST of what I expected. Wouldn't bother with this one.

this product did nothing for me..i mainly got it to add hydration around my eye area and also brighten up the area...epic fail

When it comes to eye products, I am a lazy person. I get all excited over a new eye product, pay loads of money and use it a few times, then leave it there, to use it once in a month. My room's full of products like these. When I found this, and since it was Garnier and was cheap enough to try a few times, satisfy myself for the need of buying a product and spending some money on myself even though I won't use it for long, I thought I'd give it a try. I don't know if it does help with dark circles and puffiness but it sure makes me feel good that I feel like I'm actually doing something for my skin. And it is so easy to apply, I don't have to involve my fingers and get all greasy. Also easy to carry, for sleepovers, for travelling; I put it on my night desk to apply before bed so I won't forget. It cools the area around your eyes and helps you to wake up in the morning as well. I think I'd buy this again but it's not the best eye product I have to say. It's good for lazy people like me.

I'm not to sure about this product I suffer with dark circles and am beginning to notice slight puffiness under my eyes due to stress lately and sleepless nights so I really needed something to alleviate the puffiness I massaged it on for several minutes and it made my eye area red,and wet looking it didint do anything for my circles nor my puffiness its not the circles that are bothering me it can easily be camouflaged with a good concealer but puffiness is another story so highly disappointed and to be honest can't say much for garnier I have tried their products before and never have got desired results I personally think if you want maximum results high end brands always get the desired results rather pay a bit more than get disappointed again and again this product is no exception will never buy again especially another garnier product,this roll on just sucks.

I used both the non-tinted one and the tinted one (fair), and both caused my eyes some degree of irritation and heat when applied. The tinted one was quite a good concealer, and both gave a brief, nice cooling sensation when first applied but after a few seconds, the irritation began. The non-tinted one takes a little while to be absorbed by the skin. Neither really seemed to help reduce dark shadows under my eyes, and I would say that the price is quite steep (although I'm a student, so I'm always looking for the cheapest bargain). The product does last for quite a while though.

I love this product! I've been using it for a while now, applying in the morning, before bed and before using concealer. I defiantly notice a difference, but it's not a miracle worker.

This product does nothing for me. It does not reduce puffiness or darkcircles. I wouldn't recommend it to anyone, and I won't be repurchasing.

I bought this when it first came out because I wanted to try it. I have dark circles and wanted to help get rid of them. I used it a few times and I broke out in little red bumps around my eyes. I stopped using it and was going to give it to my sister but we both decided it wasn't worth the risk. Needless to say, I ended up throwing it out. I don't know if it worked to help rid of dark circles but I definitely wouldn't recommend this if you're wanting to get a dark circle treatment. I will not repurchase.

i dont like this product at all, it was too liquidy and too harsh on my skin as the under eyes skin is so delicate it almost felt like it was burning of the skin under my eyes.. it atchully produced puffiness under my eye, other than that didnt reduce dark circles.
dont see how it can be number 1?:L

Garnier have brought out quite a few of these that seem to differ from country to country! My review is for Garnier Nutrionist Eye Roll-on in the green applicator with Caffeine and Provitamin B5.
I seem to be one of the very few who actually likes this product! I have been using it for quite a while and although I cannot honestly say that my eye bags and dark circles are completely gone, I just love the ball! I keep mine in the fridge and use it as a pick-me-up first thing in the morning and after a long hot day out. On application, the cold metal ball it is very soothing for tired puffy eyes and I find it tightens the skin and helps with swelling. The liquid gel can get a bit sticky if too much is used but I find one swipe under the eyes and under the brow is enough; I usually let it settle before dotting on an eye cream with SPF.
Take care : the product left on the ball from previous use can make the roller stick a bit, so it is important to go easy at first and avoid pulling on the skin.
For the price this a very "cool" product and I will buy it again until something better comes along.

This is the worst product I've bought this year and actually as far back as I can remember.
It does nothing in relation to what it says it will do, and I find it absolutely useless in any other way. Like for example it does not moisturize the eye area in anyway, so I can't even use it for that purpose (now that I've wasted my money anyway).
My eyes usually stings a little bit when I use this and I don't usually have sensitive skin or eyes.
.
I wouldn't recommend this to anybody.