This pencil is amazing! It stays all day but washes off easily. If you have oily lids, you might have some very very minor fading, but this is great!

A very disappointing product. Greasy, smears very easily and stays maximum 3 hours. the colour is a very hard brown, almost black...I know drug store eye pencils which do a far better job then this expensive product.

This eyeliner is great. I love the color, a deep velvety neutral to cool rich dark brown. Quite pigmented.
The pencil itself looks luxurious and the smudger is awesome.
It glides smoothly and sets rather fast, although you have time to work with it. Lasting power is above average, it doesn't smudge since it sets, only fades a bit throughout the day.
The only reason a lipstick is missing is the fact that it's not the most intense eyeliner for the waterline.
Will repurchase!

The color is beautiful and the pencil just glides on -- no tugging! It's creamy but not *too* smudgy which is perfect. My only problem with it is the staying power. Does not seem to last through lunchtime.

This is a really dreamy eyeliner!! The colour is a perfect dark brown and glides nicely onto the lash line with a trusted primer applied before hand.

I haven't used the smudger on the other end of the stick as of yet but upon feel with the finger tip it feels like it might be a little scratchy.

This eyeliner also smudges nicely with a make up brush and you can build and build this eyeliner!

You do need to reapply for a touch up after a few hours to keep your make up looking fresh but all in all it's a pretty gorgeous eyeliner and I think it might just become a personal favourite!!

Glides on really easily and the colour complements my eyes. Still it somehow doesn't stay put for more than 3 hours without or without eyeprimer.

Edit: I found a great way to keep it in place. Dab a q-tip into some hair-gel and dab it on the eyeliner which seals it for the day :)

This is a nice super soft pencil that glides on with ease compared to previous Estte Lauder Artist eye pencils and it has a very practical smudger which I like. These are quite similar to Clinique Quickliners in terms of how long it lasts on. I have a little bit hoody eye lids and whenever I wear any eye pencils I tend to get it under and over my eyes, they just dont last on me even tough I try to powder under and over, and apply shadow over sometimes it does help if I really powder and powder and use a dry finish base like Laura Mercier eye basics or Trish McEvoy base. But mostly it still smudges. I had kinda hopes for these pencils but it still smudge though it is better than many others. I bought black one and this Coffee one which is really nice deep neutral dark brown, no redness.

Love this eyeliner - the best brown ever! It glides on and lasts - brilliant. I use this most days for work and a less 'harsh' look to black eyeliner. Little expensive for what you get but will be purchasing again when i run out.