I love Orgasm, but I love Fancy Nancy even more (and I didn't think that was possible). I'm very fair complected and, as fantastic as it looks on me, I would venture a guess it would be even better against tanned skin. Definitely my new HG of lip glosses and I'll be stocking up. MK's come a long ways and apparently is no longer "your mother's makeup", because their Shy Blush is a dead ringer for Orgasm, too. Hope they keep these gorgeous (and affordable) colors going!

I love this lip gloss! I'm usually more of a pale or rosy pink or peach gloss type of girl. I got this as a gift and I thought the color would be awful on me, it looked kind of reddish with loads of sparkles (I thought for sure it would look awful on my often blotchy red skin tone). I put it on and I was so blown back, this actually compliments my skin tone more so than my usual pink lip gloss. The color is super flattering, this is not too sticky, it has a soft sort of vanilla-ish scent, and the staying power was pretty good.
If you hate sparkles or glitter in your lip product i would probably skip this though. I don't like too much glitter, but then again I don't mind the sparkles or shimmer in other lip glosses that seem to drive others wild ( I have Revlon Peach Parfait and Maybelline Babylips in Peach Kiss and many reviewers complained about the glitter or shimmer while I actually like it). I think the glitter in this makes your lips look plumper and young and fresh.

I love different levels of sheen you can build to, they are all pleasant and pretty. Alone on lips it gives a soft color with a bit of the gold shimmer very reminiscient of NARS Orgasam at 1/2 the price. Very soft fragrance too, not like the Nars which smells like chemicals. The MK Shy blush is a dead wringer for the organsm blush as well... I guess the "nice girls way" to do orgasam lol.

This is by far one of the nicest lip glosses! It's got a refreshing shade which does not age a person. The application is smooth and easy and yes, it can be slightly sticky, but then most lip glosses are :) The color is so pretty :) One can wear it from day till night

I tried Fancy Nancy - a peach-toned pink with some glitter (not too chunky) sparkle to it. It goes on quite sheer and is less intense than MAC's dazzleglass in Money Honey. I like the shade - but it is not very long wearing. Vanilla/Sweet scent (thankfully no taste) is pleasant. Glad I got this but once is enough.

If you're looking for a cheaper version of NARS Super Orgasm then this is it!
Similarities: color is pretty much spot on, down to the sparkles. I would have to say that NARS is a wee bit more pink though as you can see in the photo comparison above.
Differences: NARS is $24 for .28 oz and MK is $14 for .15 oz. So you're actually getting double the amount of product with NARS at about the same price as MK. NARS is stickier than MK and is a wee bit more opaque in my opinion. MK goes on more sheer but it's buildable coverage. NARS has that gross gasoline scent whereas there is no scent in MK's version.

Bought this along with new MK weekender lip pencil in coral stone for my beach vow renewal; gorgeous!

I bought this purely due to the name of the shade--my mom's name is Nancy. I had tried M.K.'s tinted lip balm in December and liked it, so I ordered this. I just got it today and my first impression is good. It is not sticky at all. It's a bit pricey compared to drug store brands or Avon Glazewear lip glosses. I will see how I like it over time. Probably won't buy it again but it was fun to get it in honor of my mom.

Its a great color but its also sticky and gluey on lips!
Its a shame, too, because Fancy Nancy is a great color!

This ligloss is the best! I recieved this as a gift and I thought the color would not be flattering on me, it looks very sparkly and quite dark in the tube and I normally prefer pink, peach, or clear lipgloss. This looks fantastic on. There are no chuncky sparkles on the lips, but there is a shimmer that warms the face and makes your lips look more plump. This goes on smooth, lasts a really long time for a gloss, and smells like vanilla. Whenever I know I will be in pictures I reach for this gloss because it looks so great.

i got this in a sample and i think im going to have to get it! its such a pretty color!! not to sticky, smells so good, like cupcakes? maybe thats just me though haha.

I bought this because I was looking for a color like mary kay shy blush in a lipgloss form. This is identical. The shy blush is a dupe for nars orgasm blush so I'm going to assume this lipgloss is a dupe for nars orgasm lipgloss as well. It's a perfect pinky peachy golden color. Super smooth formulation with no stickiness. Will def repurchase.

This is a gorgeous color. It's a little peach, a little pink, a little golden -- it's beautiful!

This is a review for the new Mary Kay Lip Gloss Fancy Nancy. I love this color!! I was not a fan of the Pink Diamonds - I found it too pink. I normally wear neutral lip liner with the natural lip gloss. Fancy Nancy adds just the perfect amount of shimmer and pink without being over done. It's great! I would recommend highly and will be purchasing more!