I have tried the Artliners in Black and Brown, but since curiosity always kills the cat, I went and got this in the Blueberry shade -- oh it's blue and very pretty. I just don't like the staying power of it and I think I have to shake it to make it thicker on application.

I used it over my BB Saphire Gel liner and it picked up and lightened the color to a lovely blue saphire color... It is a great shade of blue,eyeliner, but I won't buy it again.