I'm in love with this! I wear it everyday. It comes out really dark, it stays on all day, isn't expensive! The only thing I don't like is it gets onto my lashes & when I put on mascara my lashes will look clumpy. /: But other than that I love this!

I was on the brink on giving up my search for a good inexpensive liquid liner but this is it! It's very long lasting, the black is black, with a very slightly wet looking finish. It looks rather high end IMO!

It's an interesting formula because it's sort of tacky (in a good way) and it's easy to fill in thick lines with it because it's so pigmented--unlike Revlon colorstay which sort of removes liner if you swipe over it to many times trying to fill it in..--so if you like thick winged liner this might be for you.

BIG CON: The brush sucks!! especially for this odd tacky formula.. Sucks particularly if you have small lid space (asian double lid).. or long eyelashes.. the tackyness sort of ruins your lashes for mascara and it's hard to get around them with this brush. If you have a lot of lid space though you might be fine.

I HIGHLY suggest using a different brush to get the most out of this! I actually use "E.l.f. Essential Concealer Brush".. (tiny bristles, thin, long white handle) it's $1 and works really well! Worth getting if you have no brush to use with this.. the eyeliner and the brush are both cheap so.

This is probably an HG liquid liner for me and I would definitely suggest to somebody else looking for one :)

This is a really, really nice liquid liner, especially if you can snag a few when CVS has a BOGO on Milani products.
When you apply this, give it a few seconds to dry, and then it won't budge. It's the Colorstay of liquid liners, you're gonna need some heavy duty stuff to get it off, but no need to fear the smudgies.
All of the colors are truly gorgeous and pigmented, but what I can't seem to pass by is the packaging. I love a felt tip liner as much as the next girl, but it comes out with way too much product. There's no wiping mechanism, or whatever you call it, in the tube to take care of that, so quite a bit of product goes to waste. And why would anyone want to waste this lovely product?

Amazing! I praise this stuff. The to go eyeliner for asian eyes, of course, you have to have steady hands. It takes practice but it's definitely worth it! Also it comes off easily with an oil based eye make up remover.

Crap what a waste of my 8 bucks, prefer the ELF liquid eyeliner over this. Eyeliner is the most important thing for me. This products has more cons than pros IMO. Lets start with the packaging, looks good, nice and flashy gold packaging. Just don't get why the brush is this thick, the formula is goopy thick but can be worked with. This eyeliner formula is a like a tattoo, it stays put.. I mean really STAYS PUT! Removing this is a pain in my bu$$. I just use a rich cleanser to remove my makeup, don't have the time or patience for bedtime rituals. This eyeliner does not come off with a cleanser...boo on that! Try the ELF for a buck instead,

I love the coppery shade, 04 Forever. Really sets off blue eyes. The fat brush and gooey formula made it difficult to get a fine line. I will not repurchase.

Only liner that does as it says. Stays on very oily, hooded lids, in extreme humidity and in the rain. People who don't like it, says its thick and that the brush is bad. I use a separate brush, a flat one, and dab it on the wand, then remove excess on tissue... I can then use a cotton swab to thin it out, on my lid, if it went on too thick, which, for any liner, will cause some flaking. If the formula gets thicker after several uses, just place closed tube in a cup of hot water (of course not completely immersed) to thin it out.

At the end of the day, no racoon eyes, creasing, disaappearing liner. Holy Grail!

Amazing! It lasts on my eyes. Doesn't flake or smudge. Comes off easily with makeup remover. Only the brush isn't as fine a point as I'd like. The gray emphasizes my eyes without looking unnatural. I LOVE this stuff. Oh and it's cheap! I'm buying the other colors.

Compared to MAC liquidlast eyeliner, this is far better. MAC's is indeed waterproof, but not completely invincible. It's weakness is flaking. After 24 hours or swimming, parts of it flakes off. Milani's, however, does not do that. It's also paraben free unlike MAC's. I'm so happy I found a better and cheaper alternative to my everyday staple liner. :)

Pretty much an EXACT dupe of MAC liquid last eye liner. Which, in the past, was THE only liner that wouldn't melt all over my poor oily eyes/face.

But get real, who's going to pay MACs price when you can get THE EXACT PRODUCT from Milani for $6 at a drugstore (before coupons, member rewards, sales, etc). The price and staying power and color payoff CANNOT be beat.

The product can/does get thick pretty quickly and since I'm not blessed with the ability to master those stupid brushes with eyeliner, I've yet to get the finest line I want; however Milani has other options with the same staying power for that!

Overall, THIS product is what sold me on using the Milani line. I hope they never stop making products!!!!