I used a few tubes of this. It's not a bad product, it's gentle enough and efficient enough. If you use this for all the makeup on your face, including eye makeup, you end up using a lot of it everytime and the tube runs out fast.

I stopped using it because of the paraben in it.

The Japanese Curel skincare line is terrific! The makeup remover is a favorite of mine. It's a clear gel in a squeeze tube (pump would be easier but still easy to use). You take about an almond-sized blob and rub it all over your face - it spreads really well. Even my waterproof mascara/liner comes off. You can either rinse off with cool/lukewarm water, or sometimes when I'm lazy I just wipe off with a tissue and use a toner or Bioderma to get off any excess. Leaves my skin feeling soft and clean, and the 130g tube seems to last quite a while!

Like all the Curel skincare, it's fragrance/coloring/alcohol-free, but the very last ingredient is "paraben" so if you're trying to avoid em, you're out of luck.