I got this at a store closing sale for a dollar so I got a good deal. I think this is ok. It's sort of similar to what I use now, which is the CVS version of Neutrogena eye makeup remover. Both are separated and you have to shake it, however this has a few negatives for me. One, it's more greasy, two I hate the smell and three, while the bottle is cute, the CVS one has a spout and the bottle is every so slightly malleable so you can squeeze a little out instead of just shaking, which is how you have to get it out of the hard plastic bottle of the Nyx one. So since it was a dollar I guess it's all fine, but I won't buy it again. I ended up moving and getting rid of a lot of stuff so I either gave this away or tossed it. Thankfully I only spent a dollar on it.
This is a really good makeup remover dupe for the Lancome bi-facil, for a third of the price ($10). It's a tad greasy and doesn't have much of a fragrance, but does the job of removing all makeup very well. I'm already on my third bottle of this stuff, haha!
Works good, but gets a little gresy. Smells too much. Super packaging.
This remover is phenomenally effective. No rubbing required, it just melts off mascara and liner. Dirt cheap too. It's in a hard plastic bottle so you can't squeeze it out, just have to shake it onto a cotton ball. Got it half off from Cherryculture and it's one more winner by NYX.