I do like the idea of having regular and waterproof mascara in one. It's not the best but I am pretty pleased with this inexpensive mascara. The small brush reminds me of Maybelline's Great Lash (the iconic pink and green tube). The waterproof formula holds my curl and didn't flake on me. I got next to no clumps and my lashes looked longer but still natural. I was surprised the regular formula lasted me through the day without giving me raccoon eyes. It's easy to wash off. Good for everyday wear or if you like layering with other mascara types.

the ones i bought came completely dried out so i wasnt even able to try em out at all

Wow, talk about alot of bad reveiws! Im so suprised because I LOVE this product and I have tried popular drugstore mascara's AND high end mascara's.
BTW~i naturally have very long lashes that dont need curling. So I dont know how this would work on someone with short, lashes that need lots of curl n such.
PROS:
`Makes my lashes super dark and obvious:) They really look false!
`Gives me tons of volume and enhances my length
`Doesnt flake or wear off
`Looks aammaazzing:)
`Does EVERYTHING we want in a mascara (at least for me it did)
`The price! I got this at walgreens for 99 cents :D
CONS"
` im a little worried about how fast this is going to run out becuase the ends are so small, but if it does go fast i can just buy another to keep in my purse only for touch ups or travel bag ( =

~~~~i will update in a few days or week to tell you if i am still loving or not! But all i can say right now is BUY BUY BUY, this stuff is great!

I honestly didn't really like this mascara. I had really high hopes for this mascara especially because this was my first ever mascara and I heard a lot of people say it was good but for me, it wasn't really. Both sides really clumped on my lashes and after 5 minutes of wearing it, my lashes would become really dry and flaky. I also didn't notice that big of a difference between the 2 sides based on lenghtening and defining. Also, the packaging, (I don't know if this only happens to mine), whenever I close it, mascara tends to squirt out of the sides and it gets really annoying. I didn't find this mascara to be that volumizing. It is a very pigmented black colour and it lengthens a little, but the flakiness and clumpyness of this product wasn't good for me.

This mascara does not provide any length or volume, nor does it make your lashes look any different. Along with that, it kind of clumps. However, it is waterproof and lasts all day. I think that it's good for an everyday school look. But it doesn't really do much; you won't notice a difference.

I agree that it's not waterproof at all and left blobs under my eyes even after it set. I also agree the formulation is on the drier side. The only good things I found were:
- it was cheap (less than Cdn $5)
- didn't clump going on or flake throughout the day
- curled my lashes somewhat
I would have liked it way more if it didn't leave blobs under my eyes which is almost as bad as smudges. Won't buy again. :(

I ordered two of these, on in black and one in black brown. The waterproof was very dry when I first opened it, but the regular was semi-wet. I like wet mascaras, so I wasn't a big fan. After about a week both ends were completely dried out. I think it is a packaging fault because I made sure the caps were closed tight because they were so dry already. I was not expecting much, but these were still a disapointment. Also, the black brown color was a very light brown color. Usually it is much darker in other brands, so I'm wondering if I received a mislabled product. Also, the smell was bad.

I bought this a day before a water park trip at school, and I was horrified when I went into the bathroom and the mascara was completely off. NOT WATERPROOF AT ALL. And when you wash your face it comes off in flakes. But I use it despite this, because the brush is so small I can make my corner eyelashes flare out, just how I like it. So yes, I still use it despite it not being actually waterproof, but I will not repurchase.

I got this mascara at my local Target. I must say I am a HUGE E.L.F fan.. so I brought it thinking I would love it.... man was I wrong! My tube wasn't dried out at all, its just really thick. It goes on extremely heavy, and not to mention that the wand on my waterproof side broke as soon as I got it. I really wanted to give it a chance... and I did.. but I had to stop and buy a new mascara. Maybe I had a crappy one, but the quality was just awful! and I hate saying that because E.L.F usually has such awesome things.

I picked this up at my local Dollar Tree awhile back and I must say that I am pretty impressed by it. Ill give it a 4 out of 5 because I love my Maybelline Falsies mascara wayy better but if you want a nice and simple mascara and nothing dramatic, this is it. I paid $1 for it, it lasts all day and I would def buy again.