EM sent me two of these free with my order, so I can't complain...but I was surprised. First of all, they're not glosses. More of a balm with a bit of color--like a bad version of Burt's Bees Lip Shimmer. Very waxy-dry and kind of weird-smelling, and the colors they sent me were odd. Siesta is a strange orangey-nude that went on kind of streaky and left little lumps of product on my lips. Coffee Shop looked almost black in the tube but went on as a very sheer, slightly grey-mauve shimmer. Coffee Shop wasn't terrible, but I'd never buy these...nice of EM to save me from ordering them. :-) I love the other EM products I've tried, so these surprised me. I guess no company can do everything right, though!