I only use the primer because the liner sealer does not work for me. The primer is good enough, but still doesn't compare to eyelid primers like Urban Decay. I wish they only made the primer stick because I feel like the other half is such a waste. Also, I use eye makeup almost every day and I have been using this every day for the past few months haven't even hit the bottom yet! A little goes a long way.
I purchased this for the liner, so I can't rate the primer aspect (because I use the Fergie primer at walgreens and feel no need to try anything else). I wanted a sparkly silver liner for New Year's Eve, so I bought this and a cheap NYC silver loose eyeshadow thing. I dipped the liner in, and it created a bright, sparkly silver eyeliner that was exactly what I wanted! It stayed on well, and didn't migrate or have any fallout. Therefore, I would recommend this to make a liner out of any shadows you might have.
I bought this for the line sealer. Overall this product isn't good
The primer is not bad. Like other reviewers have said you kind if have to warm it up a bit so it can be applied better but for the price it does a pretty good job. I haven't used the line sealed yet. I would re-purchase definetely!
I dont use a liner wo this review is based soley on the primer. Nothing special but it isnt horrible. I have a natural crease in my eyelid so my eyeshadow is gonna crease regardless if I use a cheap primer, the most expensive, or the one rated as the best. As for the other areas of my eyes I believe this primer holds my eyeshadow in place very well despite my very greasy eyelids.
A really neat little product concept. The primer is excellent its slightly harder than your average concealer but warm it up a little with your finger and it's fine. Looks rather yellowy peachy in the tube but it hides redness/any veins on your lids for perfect shadow application - and boy does it amplify the intesity of your shadow. Unfortunately it creases within hours I'm better off not wearing a primer than this.
the liner sealer is workable but can make a real mess - all in all wouldn't rate this product.
Do people even read the product directions? You're not supposed to use this over eyeliner (I know from the name it sounds that way) you're supposed to swipe it in an eyeshadow and then use it as a liquid eyeliner. From the website and packaging: "The Liner side transforms your favorite eye shadow into a waterproof, smudge-proof liquid liner with this unique clear liquid and built-in felt tip precision eyeliner brush."
I like to use it with my pigments or Bare Escentual loose eyeshadows. Really neat way to get unique coloured eyeliners! When used as its intended, my liner lasts all day. Really impressed.
I do not line the primer on this, so I'm only really reviewing about the sealer. That's why I took of a point for the overall rating; the primer is pretty crappy in my opinion.
The sealer is a lifesaver, however. It keeps my gel/cream liner in place. I have very oily eyelids, and usually the only thing that stays on is liquid liner, however liquid liner always gets all over my lashes while I'm applying it. I prefer the gel liner. So I apply my gel liner, then I apply the sealer and it stays all day. There might be a tiny bit of smudging, but no where near what it used to be. I can even do liner on my lower line and apply this on top, and it stays! I do have problems with the liner staying on the outside corner of my eyes (yes I do apply primer there), but no where near what I used to.
I wish it came without the primer. I don't use it and it'll go to waste. I've been using one of the other ELF primers and it works great.
I liked the primer side better then the liner side. Just because the liner side stung, but also I didn't really have a use for it.... But I would definitely reconnect the primer side!!
The Liner Sealer:
Isn't good at all. Tried using it, and frankly it just made a mess on my eyes. I don't recommend anyone use this part just because the product sucks. The packaging is adorable cause I slip it into my purse and no problems.
I give the Liner sealer a 2/5 l/s
Awesome at times. When i'm getting ready, I put it under a light or blow dryer for a few seconds to get the primer a little creamy because it's a little rough on the eye lid especially when you shouldn't tug on the eye to prevent wrinkles. So it's good a little heated and it does not crease or anything like that.
I give it 4/5