I have really begun to like Maybelline products. Good quality at a reasonable price. packaging isn't great but I don't mind as long as it stays intact. I'd rather pay for better quality ingredients.
I was after GREY tones for ages and , like the previous reviewer, got one which was too taupe/beige. This one is a perfect grey - one silvery and the other dark. perfect to blend together, or mix with other eye colours and great for a smoky look. I particularly like that they aren't shimmery. I wouldn't call them utterly matte but I reach for this as a daytime shadow frequently.
I guess this is discontinued as I could only find it on ebay after trawling the local chemists etc for a suitable, not glittery/shimmery grey without success.
Found this at the Dollar Tree. I needed a taupe e/s but most of the ones I'd come across were too brown for my skintone. This one is perfect. The darker shade is a greyish brown & the lighter is a silver/gray tone. Matte finish. I find myself reaching for this all the time so I think I need to buy a backup of it.