I got this cleanser in a swap and I am so glad I got the chance to try it! It foams wonderfully, takes all my face makeup off, and rinses away easily, without drying my skin out. If it came in a pump bottle, and smelled a little better, I would never use anything else again, at least in winter when my skin is drier. FYI I use eye makeup remover for my eye makeup so I can't say how well it does with waterproof mascaras. Since I got this in a swap from a girl in Singapore, I'm not sure if I'll be able to find another bottle but I said I would repurchase it.