This definitely looks black until you get up close when the metallic olive-brown is apparent. If the brush hadn't been frayed and wonky I'd've given it a 5. I'll probably Franken it now. I got it at Walgreens for $2.99.
Gorgeous color. It's black with a gold and olive sheen. A gold-y black if that makes sense. The shimmer is awesome. The formula is nice and thick, it goes on perfect with two coats. I also love the bottle, big fat fake gem on top :p