I bought this for half off. I'm glad I did because this was a major disappointment and i would not have wanted to pay $8 for it. This pencil was way too fragile and creamy. Every time i tried to apply it, it crumbled away into nothing. It took me ten minutes to line one eye and smudge the liner to get it even in the crumbled spots. I was expecting so much from this worse-than dollar store quality eyeliner.