I don't know what the rest of the lip frostings are like, but this as an underwhelming whipped cream scent. This is the only one I have, and I like that it's slippery, not sticky, and goes on smoothly.
The scent is good, and the light light lavender sheen goes in a good pair with my pink lipsticks. I do find that the application and the packaging is cute! I like it.
For a cheap product, it's a nice pick-me-up. :)
I noticed Bonne Bell came out with a new line of Lip Frostings when I was at Wal-Mart and, being the lip gloss whore that I am, I got one in Confetti. I thought it would smell similar to the Birthday one, but this has almost no scent at all, it smells faintly of marshmallows. Thin, slippery texture, not long lasting. Wouldn't recommend this. I'll still use it when I feel like reapplying because I do like the scent, but would not repurchase.