I got this product in natural nymph. And first off it looked like I put concealer on my lips. It made my lips look really dry. So I gave it to my sister and it made her lips look dry too. So I decided to just go and buy it in a different color. And I got it in pouty petal this time to see if it was just the shade this time. And it end being a better choice. It didn't make my lips look dry and it looked smoother on my lips.

I bought these two on a whim because ELF was doing a free shipping event for a purchase of $25 and over. So I decided to try these out. I got Rosy Raisin and Rosy Tan. Both very similar except Rosy Raisin tends to be more of a light sheerer nude pink while Rosy Tan tends to be more brownish and a darker nude pink. I love these both but find myself wearing Rosy Tan more!


Pros:
Beautiful colors
Great color pay off
Stains even after you wipe it off before you eat and etc
Long wearing (3-4 hours +)
Amazing texture (very creamy and feels like a lip balm)


Cons:
Not true to color on website, must look at swatches online
Can settle into creases
Rosy Raisin is sheerer but Rosy Tan is more opaque (inconsistent?)
The shape of the bullet is weird

i have this lipstick in rustic brick, which is a brownish color a bit too dark for everyday wear for my skin tone, and rosy tan, which is a wonderful color (for me, it's like a your-lips-but-better shade). it feels really smooth and buttery, but it definitely settled into the cracks of my lips. an okay product.

I have this in ripe rose and it is such a wearable shade of red. I had one other shade which I ended up giving to someone as it has shimmer but this one is great. It literally feels like a lip balm. I want to try few other shades from this line.I got this at 50% discount, so for $2.50 it is a steal. Love elf in general.

I have this in Rustic Brick and it's the perfect warm, sort of -reddish brown colour for me. I even stocked up and bought two extras of these, just in case - and I never do that with products.

I love these lipsticks! It stays on for a long time and the colors of this line are amazing! I have too many of these and they're great for everyday looks! They're not flaring bright or too sheer. My favorite one is Rosy Tan and Rosy Raisin. Totally recommend these if you're looking for a cheap lipstick that's really good!

This is a great lipstick. I have it in Rich Raspberry , which looks a lot different online, but is still a great color. I always tend to wear reds and pinks, and this color turned out to be more of a berry color but i love it! I always use it and it feels so smooth on my lips. I am definitely looking forward to trying more colors out :)

i have this lipstick in party pink, but i dont really like the colour. but i like the finish it gives!

I freaking love this lip stick. I have it in Runway Pink and its just a perfect, natural pink for everyday :) The packaging is very sleek and chic, which I love, and the texture is smooth and hydrating. Great lip stick for $5

I love this entire lipstick line. I have woefully dry, peeling, cracked lips and these do NOT settle in the lines. Not only that, they feel great--like a smooth and thin lip balm. They have no taste, no smell and the packaging is sturdy. They have good pigmentation, do not feather around my lip lines, and are reasonably priced. I really see no cons to it whatsoever. These are simply amazing.