the color is very beautiful,but the stuff is super dry,and looks terrible on lips.it can make all the lines and dry patches show.and another drawback that I can't deal with:the disgusting soaplike smell of all NYX round lipsticks,which hangs around for a long time even after I wipe the color off completely.

I would never ever have gotten this lipstick if I hadn't seen a YouTube guru use it. The name pumpkin pie makes it sound as though its a harsh orange color, not a beautiful nude. I love how nude lips look on everyone else but I have never gotten one that is actually flattering. It's really hard to describe this color, it's like a nudish, bronzish, peachish color mixed to perfection (if that makes any sense at all!). This feels soft and moist on my lips and I don't get any weird build up on my lips from reapplying...which leads to the downside, that it is not very long lasting, but I don't mind reapplying. This also does not dry out my lips like a lot of MAC lipsticks do. This is not a nude that people will look at you and think, "oh she's wearing nude lipstick" it just lightens my lips a bit and makes my lips look soft, healthy and pretty.

I guess I was expecting something more opaque, based on my experiences with other Nyx round lipsticks. I just got this one in the mail and it feels very much like a slick lip balm on my lips. It's also very sheer and since my natural lip color is pigmented, it settles into the lip lines and shows every imperfection. The color itself is a pretty beigey peach and it looks nice with lip gloss over it. I have dry skin and I like moisturizing lipsticks but this one feels like it would slide right off. With a lip liner it's improved but it's not something I see myself reaching for. I'm sad because the swatches look so pretty on other girls! I guess my hunt for a nice matte peachy-beige continues.

I like this a lot! I have very pigmented pink lips, and when I apply this over them it turns out to be a very pretty light peach color. The formula is very creamy and moisturizing feeling. Personally, I don't smell or taste anything. The only con is the shimmer. The first time I applied it I felt the shimmer was too overbearing for everyday wear. The thing is, once you work through the first layer of the lipstick in the tube I think the shimmer decreases. Maybe that's just my imagination. But now that I've used this a few times it's perfect for an everyday lip! I think this would go nicely on a lot of skintones, especially fair/warm. I'd buy again.

I am happy with the color of this lipstick, but there are just too many cons. It was hard for me, too, to find a color that didn't make me look dead. This color has just enough pinky-orange to make the good pale orange nude I was looking for, but everytime I wear it, I wish I hadn't put it on. It's thin, not long lasting, and the TASTE is horrible. That perfumey air freshener scent always rubs into my mouth. Blech.

Ugh, I wish I would have read the feedback here first! I am so disappointed! While I loved the color "Rea" the extra creamy formula, the color, the color stay (easily comparable another brand in texture) and convincing myself to tolerate the very faint smell of citronella, you know the bug spray smell, although minimal, I was a gasp when I licked my lips and they tasted worst than the lipstick smelled! I literally tasted perfume, as though I had sprayed it in my mouth (no, I am NOT exaggerating)! Too bad I bought 3 tubes, I haven't tried the other two, unexcited anyway, as the matte colors on the ULTA website do not look like the FLUORESCENT colors I received. Big waste of money for me!
On that note, I have written to the company and am looking forward to hearing back, hopfully they will fix this issue!

This is a great product, I find it hard to fine good lip colours for me so I thought I'd try this out. I paired it with NYX round lipgloss in real nude and it looks great on my lips. I think this is going to be one of the staples in my life. NYX please never stop making this!!!!!

This is one of my favorite nude lipsticks. I love the color and the way it pops on my lips, especially with clear lip gloss. It doesn't look ashy or cakey, which is why I like it so much.

I really had high hopes for this color. Everyone's been raving about it and I just had to go and try it myself. I'm an NC30-35 and I've been looking for a great nude lipstick.
You see, my lips are a bit bluish and purplish as I was born with a heart defect. But since the reviews are so good, I thought it would be good on me as well....sadly, the colors dont show on my lips :( It looked like an ugly gloss and was very uneven no matter how many coats i put on :(

I love this color!!!
- My skintone is about a NW30 foundation color in mac and this is the prettiest color lipstick i have had in a LONNNGGG time...
Its smooth to apply, not sticky at all and very creamy (maybe a little to creamy for sometimes)
But its nothing i care to dwell on.
The only fault i can really find is the taste and smell of it. It does smell like a cheap lipstick HA! But hey - it is super cheap! What ya gunna complain about now? :-)

I have medium-skin tone. NC35 to be exact. This is sooooo gorgeous on medium skin tone! This is the perfect nude lip stick! It doesnt make me look sick. Very hard to find a great nude color for medium skin tone. The texture is also very creamy and it lasts fairly oaky around 2 hours before it starts to rub off without eating or drinking. What I dont like about this is that since my lips are pigmented, it tends to highlight the lines on my lips so i had to get a lip concealer from etude house. But the color is really great. A pale peach color with a slight coral tinge to it. This is my go to everyday wear as i like to do my eyes a lil dramatic..LOVE! will definitely repurchase

I am quite impressed with this lipstick! I bought it on an impulse and thought that this could pass off as a shimmer nude color. However, upon application, the coral in this lipstick became much more prominent, giving a really nice, MLBB color! I absolutely adore the color, and from a random lipstick in my stash, this has been promoted to my everyday go-to color for school and casual days.
Perhaps one thing, would be the lasting power of all NYX's lipstick. They're not that fanstastic and a reapplication throughout the day is definitely needed. For the price, I'm willing to look over this!
Definitely will repurchase this once I'm outta this color! I'll look into other colors as well :)

Sorry NYX, first really bad review> sorry to bore your all been a senior pro artist for 20 years. I hate this colour, hardly any colour pay off yet it is one of the biggest sellers in the round lipsticks. You get what you pay for, I bought a haul and overall would not buy them again>.Save you money for the black label or matt, NYX glosses also decent quality.Many of the round label have a shimmer, which I absolutely loathe. Yes these are a steal for students, or people on a tight budget, but definitely not up to pro standards at all, I purchased 6 and this one I disliked the most, very sheer, did not last on lips a minute, although lips were thoroughly prepared for the shoot. Did not stand up to the lighting, Indian pink is a nice colour but has shimmer, Louisiana more pigment. a similar colour, but not near same league a nars, vitamin more shimmer, Strawberry milk and orange soda are my pick from this haul, matt but not matt enough to last on lips very long. My tip, use a primer, then neutral lip liner. NYX are decent lip liners. or Mac spice would be my choice, apply round lipstick, powder over with some HD powder then re apply, but that is time consuming for most people. Other than the two I mentioned, I'll stick solely with higher end matt products.SORRY NYX BUT IM ALWAYS HONEST continued >>

I'm nc20 and have had a hard time finding a pretty neutral that don't make me dead and this color is it! I love how it adds a pretty peach color to my lips and it's very moisturizing will def. buy it again!

I'm about NC 20 and this color is gorgeous on me, a perfect neutral color. It has a great feel and finish -- they are very pigmented, really creamy, smooth and have a slight glossy sheen. Ugh, but the taste is horrible! It smells like a floral perfume and tastes like one too. Even the tiniest contact makes me feel like I'm eating soap. I have never been sensitive to the smells or tastes of any of the zillions of lipglosses or lipsticks I've tried but this one is something I can't stand. Such a shame I can't use anything from this line.

The only way I can get this to look ok is with lip gloss layered over it. On it's own...no. It's weird, this lipstick almost has an oily texture (slipperyt?) yet settles into the lines on my lips- not very flattering. And my lips aren't dry or chapped either so there's no reason for it. And the shade itself on my lips (which are very red and pigmented) isn't flattering. It's like a peach/praline-y kinda color that sits on my lips and doesn't absorb. It just looks cheap on my mouth and very uneven. Wearing gloss over it kinda helps and makes it more wearable, but even so I like my lipstick to perform well on its own. I have other colors from this NYX line and I like them a lot more and they don't feel as weird and slippery and look a lot better. I'm totally returning this if I can find the receipt...

I really like this color. I was worried it was a little too orange from pics but it's not at all. And for the price it's a steal. 4 lippies!

A nice nude beige peach colour with some pink in it. I love how ceamy NYX lipsticks are. A nice nude colour for girls with medium/tan skintones or darker skintones too. I took off one lippie cause they don't have very good staying power you have to re-apply quite often. But for the price and colour will buy this product again. This colour is a good dupe for MAC's shy girl lipstick.

this doesn't look peachy on my NC35 skin/ darkly pigmented lips. It pulls more of a neutral light pinky shade which i love b/c I cannot pull of beigy nudes cos it washes me out. The fragrance is strong but you get used to it & now i hardly notice it. It is on the sheerer side but it compliments my skin tone nicely. The NYX lipsticks are very soft & creamy so you won't get long wear out of this, but considering the price & balm like feel its nice reapply this. continued >>

This is an okay lipstick. I have to apply a lot of product to get some color since it was too sheer for me. And even so, it barely shows up on my lips. It wasn't what I thought it was going to be but it does make a MLBB lipstick.