I have tried many liquid liners from Revlon colorstay to Almay and they all hurt stung my eyes. This is the first liquid liner that didn't hurt my eyes when applying. It's cheap, it's stays, it's jet black. What else can you ask for? Try it out l...

In the same way that there is nothing more disappointing than spending £25 on an item you pin your hopes on but which turns out to be just a bit crap, there is nothing more heartening than spending a few quid on something which knocks your socks off. This eyeliner is super-easy to apply, with really smooth, even application. It is mega black and really pigmented, stays put once it's dry, but washes off easily. Magic.

I always repurchase this eyeliner. It's really easy to work on the lid, it's very black and intense and it stays quite a while. I always use it over a thin layer of sheer eyeshadow and it doesn't move. If I wear it directly on the skin, like any other liquid eyeline, it fades. The lids tend to be greasy or to sweat because we keep our eyes open. But the eyeshadow trick is perfect for me.

This is a strange eyeliner. The "nib" is not a brush like a traditional liquid eyeliner, it's more a plastic, hairless pointer. However, with a bit of practice, it's easy enough to use. The formula is average, it isn't waterproof, fades after about 2 hours to a patchy grey, and will smudge within about 4 hours. One good thing about this eyeliner is that it is very black. For a better budget buy try Collection 2000.

New Zealand, $13.95

I've repurchased this several times, probably because I'm too lazy to find something better. Considering the price, it's a crazy good liquid eyeliner. I love the felt tip it has and how long the tiny pottle lasts. I find the coverage a little off, it's definitely not me being bad at eyeliner, I promise. I always notice spots along my eyelashes that aren't black but it's nothing major.

For a cheap eyeliner, it certainly does the trick. You do get what you pay for but on the cheap, it's probably the best out there.

I have been using this eye liner every day for several years. It gives a nice smooth line over my eye lid. However, I do find it difficult to draw a thin line and after using it frequently it the brush goes funny and makes it extremely hard to use. It is so cheap that I can easily go out and buy a new one.

Pros
Good price for an eyeliner
Quick application
No strong smell


Cons
Dries up
Too small

I'm rubbish at applying liquid liner but this makes it much easier and stays on all day.

Adore this so much. It is so easy to apply, doesn't come off over the course of the day even when rubbed slightly (and has survived through many workouts), its a gorgeous jet black and on top of it all is so cheap! You may think this is another standard drug store eyeliner but it is so good and i recommend it very highly. I wear a thick line of eyeliner with a cats eye flick at the end. I was worried the applicator was too thin but you can angle it for ANY thickness. It's a sponge applicator, and is rigid but doesn't drag your eyelid. Love it.

I'm fairly new to using liquid eyeliner, I've always been more comfortable using pencil liner, but I decided I wanted to try out liquid for maybe the second time ever. Last time I got a dirt cheap liner that was awful, and while Rimmel's liner isn't that expensive it was definitely better quality. The brush is very thin, which is lovely, and the liner is very dark. However, it did seem that the brush being so thin led to me getting it all over without realizing. Maybe when I've had some more practice with it I'll enjoy it more.