I quite like this one. the texture feels just right, it sinks in nicely and it doesn't contain loads of annoying shiny particles like some YR eye creams do. it doesn't make tiny lines magically disappear and I'm not sure I'm seeing any lifting effect (hence I'm not giving it the full 5 lippies), but it seems to moisturize impressively and it doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes (I think it has no fragrance).