*sigh* I think I just need to admit that I'm pretty much never gonna like pencil eyeliners.

The only thing I like them for is tightlining, and even then, I'm picky.


message by kragey
more messages

expand whole thread*sigh* I think I just need to admit that I'm pretty much never gonna like pencil eyeliners.kragey2/5/2013 2:10PM

I carry them in my purse for touch-ups during the day; don't use to lineRedHeDD2/5/2013 3:00PM

me neither. haven't been wearing any all this time.hammsandwich2/5/2013 2:33PM

I've given up on liquid/gel eyeliner. Smudged pencil is my favoritecgw12/5/2013 2:30PM

I think I will never like anything else but pencils;-) Have been using them for 25+ years and find +Lizzy282/5/2013 2:22PM

I don't even own any pencil eyeliners. paulapop2/5/2013 2:21PM

I like how soft and blendy they are, but with or w/o primer, they smudge on me. :(Shryh12/5/2013 2:19PM

I don't like them either - give me gel liners anyday!suzq252/5/2013 2:17PM

I even like e/s wet better than pencils. I have always hated pencil liners and I'm oldsuzq252/5/2013 2:32PM

I love liquid but I am on a pencil kick at the moment.Conny682/5/2013 2:16PM

pencils take so much work. i like gels and liquid. i use a auto liner for my waterlineBlubandit852/5/2013 2:14PM

ditto. i prefer using e/s wet or gelsgizmorules2/5/2013 2:14PM

Pencil e/l is pretty much the only form of e/l I reach for these daysicloverbby2/5/2013 2:13PM

Me too. I don't have a pencil liner at the moment and I don't mindtraxfever2/5/2013 2:13PM

Me neither...I really need to purge mine because I only ever use cake liners. I am lemming the new +kaykre2/5/2013 2:12PM

yeah I have like 10 pencils and one liquid and I use my liquid one dailyangiee02152/5/2013 2:12PM

I think I'm off gels... such an awkward hybrid lolmadeupstories2/5/2013 2:11PM

I haven't been using my gel liners at all lately. And my Inglots all dried out *sadz*leeleebell2/5/2013 2:12PM

nooooo :(madeupstories2/5/2013 2:13PM

As much as I loved em, they do suck for drying so soon. Since I rarely use gels it seems pointless+ leeleebell2/5/2013 2:16PM

KATE is the only gel I've ever finished -- creamy to the last scraping ;)madeupstories2/5/2013 2:17PM

I'm okay with gels and creams, but liquid will probably always be my favorite.kragey2/5/2013 2:12PM

I'm too lazy about reaching for that separate brush these daysmadeupstories2/5/2013 2:13PM

I don't like them because they catch my eye skin and pull :( I never get a clean linebeautyglitter2/5/2013 2:11PM

My problem is that they tend to smear/smudge on my brow bone, no matter what I do, butkragey2/5/2013 2:13PM

i agree with the staying power of liquids and gels. I don't do smudging.beautyglitter2/5/2013 2:14PM

I'm the opposite, I like gel and liquids but allllways come back to pencils D:lomelindi2/5/2013 2:10PM